[Editor's note: This is an Op-Ed piece by Ray Rothrock, a partner at venture capital firm Venrock.]

New Electrons Powering the Planet
There is a tremendous opportunity in what I call “new electrons” to help drive a substantial change in the energy source of modern society. New electrons are technologies and techniques that efficiently harness and store energy and electricity. New electrons, in Venrock’s view, is the most promising area of venture investing. New electrons could have a major impact because they significantly reduce emissions from fossil fired electric plants and make better use of all the fuels currently produced.

Ethanol and biofuels have been popular fuel sources, yet adoption has been slow, they have proven to be only marginally economical and they rely on heavy government subsidies. Gasoline is a fuel that is manufactured, understood, used and safe but has plagued our planet with carbon emissions. How can fuel be refined better and stored more effectively so that it is environmentally sound and provides clean energy? How do we preserve the planet’s ecological community of life if new energy sources are not lasting, and require more resources to ultimately generate the power?

This is where new electrons come in and Venrock has identified several approaches.

More Miles Per Gallon
Venrock invested in Transonic Combustion as it represents a new electron by improving internal combustion engine efficiency. In other words, it minimizes the volume of carbon emissions by developing a way to reduce the amount of gasoline or other liquid fuels needed to go the same distance as engines today. With a goal of 100 miles per gallon in a stock car, Transonic is working on an “injection ignition” engine that can run efficiently on gasoline, ethanol or other fuel without electric assist or major engine modifications. A key aspect of the technology is a revolutionary new type of fuel injector. This injector can be supplemented by advanced thermal management, EGR, electronic valves, and advanced combustion chamber geometries for even better utilization of a unit of fuel. As an investor, I may be biased. But I believe Transonic represents possibly the most significant improvement in internal combustion efficiency engines in decades.

Battery Power
Our mobile society needs energy everywhere. People are all carrying devices that run on energy – mobile phones, iPods, laptops, radios and surveillance systems. It is clear that we need to have cheap, clean portable power.

Battery power is one of the most important areas of new electrons. Its challenge is how to get the most power out of the smallest battery unit. There are some emerging techniques in battery power that provide new sources of clean energy and methods for storage. These batteries last longer, weigh less, have a miniature footprint and require shorter times to charge and recharge.

Boston Power, another Venrock investment, represents a new electron for portable clean energy: it harnesses the power of lithium in a safe and environmentally sustainable way by increasing the lifetime of batteries. Last year, you might remember the unfortunate incident when a Dell laptop violently exploded. It was powered by lithium, a potentially dangerous element when not properly used. Much like a microphone’s sound can break your ear drum when there is too much feedback, the battery used on that laptop experienced a similar chemical reaction: when the elements reinforced one another, it kept generating heat and power, leading to the fire. It is a chemistry issue and Boston Power invented a way to address it. Boston Power is reusing conventional battery materials that self regulate, to sense feedback and naturally shut down when it gets too hot. It is focused on generating power and storing it through alternative means, safely for longer run times as well.

Fuel cell technology is a different kind of new electron. It gained popularity in the 1960s with the NASA space program. After more than 40 years of research, it is now being selectively deployed commercially. Fuel cell technology is based mostly on hydrogen, the lightest element in the universe. Hydrogen is plentiful and comes with unique chemical and physical characteristics. Fuel cell technology, as a source of green energy, has reemerged in distinct, specialty scenarios as society goes mobile and as military and law enforcement needs intensify.

For those in our military forces, it can save lives. Venrock invested in Jadoo Power, for example, which is making a power pack for the US Special Operations Command. The goal is to reduce the weight of energy storage carried in the field. Imagine you’re on the front lines and you want to survey miles ahead. Rather than send your soldiers into unknown terrain, surveillance devices that run on fuel cell technology can go in their place. With a limited heat signature and light weight, it can last weeks longer than a device running with conventional sources of energy.

Preserving Nature with Nuclear Power
Harnessing nuclear power, the most powerful energy source in the universe, is another example of a new electron. Nuclear energy is clean because it does not involve burning fossil fuels - the largest source of emissions of carbon dioxide, one of the greenhouse gases that contribute to global warming. Today, nuclear fission power generation is much safer and currently provides about 17% of electricity in the US. It also powers many of our Navy’s ships without incident. France generates three-quarters of its electricity with nuclear fission power. Improving the way we harness nuclear energy is an important area of exploration for the venture community because of its tremendous, industrial impact. How we deal with nuclear waste, though, is a political challenge, not a technical one. Public support for nuclear fission plants in the United States greatly diminished in the last three decades. Emerging economies like China are purchasing new plants form US manufacturers as this is written. It’s time to seriously reconsider nuclear fission as a viable option and commence construction.

Shaping our Planet’s Future
Individually, we can all work on our carbon footprint by driving a more fuel efficient car, better insulating our home or using compact fluorescent light bulbs. However, ultimately, advances in energy have to be at the scale of our major power grids. Venture capital makes its mark on big applications for clean energy on this industrial scale. It takes time, but both must happen.

Regardless of the vast supply of fossil fuels, it is no longer an option to be so dependent on this source of fuel for our energy needs. The entrepreneurs that focus on new electrons – innovation that allows generation of power through alternative means efficiently and creates a way to store it – are those that are building companies that shape our planet’s future.

Trackback URL

3 Trackbacks

  1. Transonic’s goal: a car engine that gets 100 miles per gallon « IT Spot said:

    [...] Meanwhile, earlier this month, Venrock partner Ray Rothrock wrote a bit about the company in a column on VentureBeat. [...]

  2. Cleantech Investing » Blog Archive » EnerTech, Secure Energy, Reklaim, Thermilate, and other news said:

    [...] Cleantech investors in the news: Ray Rothrock lays out Venrock’s investment strategy in “new electrons”. [...]

  3. VentureBeat » Nuclear innovations — will they lure cleantech capital? said:

    [...] Hyperion, for example, is backed by a little-known firm called Purple Mountain Ventures. And Venrock Capital’s own Ray Rothrock has written a contributor piece for VentureBeat advocating nuclear investment. [...]

11 Comments

  1. Nuclearnotsogreen said:

    This is otherwise an excellent piece, but you are overlooking the greenhouse gas emissions, radiation, and other pollution that come from mining nuclear materials, not to mention the problem of nuclear waste that not a single brilliant engineer has solved for good.

  2. Ray Rothrock said:

    Thanks for the comment. Actually in the case of mining, radioactive emissions from uranium mining is real and comparable to coal mining and other forms of mining as well. Disturbing the earth as mining does always releases gases, some radioactive and some not. It’s very dependent on the exact geology of course.

    WIth regard to radioactive emissions coal is even more problematic. Coal emits when burned radioactive gas, radium, which is inherently in the earth and therefore coal. It goes right out the stack into the air. It is very hard to prevent this. I’d really not want to live downwind from a coal plant for this and many other reasons. Did you have to have a radium test when you purchased your home? If you had a basement, you probably did.

    As for nuclear waste, I must disagree based on what I learned and saw when I was in the nuclear industry. In the 70’s I visited the Navy’s reprocessing facility and saw it actually working up close and personal. The ultimate disposal of long-lived radioactive material is, in my opinion, mostly (if not entirely) political The technology for managing it, keeping it contained and isolated, and moving it around is well known, tested, and widely known. A lot of brilliant engineers have indeed worked on it with great success.

    Every thing is a trade-off of course. And all facets of modern society must be considered when making energy source decisions, including the politics. I just get bummed out when folks lay it off on the engineers that a problem (waste management) has not been solved when, in fact, it really has. We need to make tough choices, or the radium will continue to go up the stack at an ever increasing rate.

  3. Don Jones said:

    Ray,

    You didn’t mention solar. Is this just an area of incremental improvement as photo cell costs are driven down and not very interesting to you, or…?

  4. Anthony Kuhn said:

    Thanks for cheerleading the need for VCs to invest in alternative fuel startups and businesses. You’ll have lots of company in the near future! I cross-posted on your piece to http://blog.innovators-network.org
    IN is a non-profit dedicated to bringing technology to startups, small businesses, non-profits, venture capitalists and intellectual property experts. Please visit us and help grown our community!

    Best wishes for continued success,

    Anthony Kuhn
    Innovators Network

  5. gluphus said:

    It seems to me there is a large market opportunity in systems that help people do more with less. Affordable/intelligent smart home products could reduce the average families energy and water usage 30-70% without any lifestyle change.

    Are the VC’s/angels thinking about helping companies that do that, not just refining hydrocarbon cracking or alt fuels?

    IMHO, this should also be a policy focus, its less expensive, easier to implement and gives the masses a feeling that they are helping. I guess the downside is such policy only benefits individuals and small companies, not multinationals and big government….

  6. Edward said:

    Nanotechnology is the other science I would have championed as a future efficient source of new energy producing and energy saving products.
    Most would agree that our future will be transformed into a society where energy sources are more benign and efficient. However, I think that the greatest impediment to the introduction of new energy technology, is mainly politics and local social acceptance.
    Next time you see a futuristic movie depict their version of a city, consider all the zoning regulations, power distribution issues, environmental aesthetics concerns, safety regulations at the local, regional, national, and international level. And you will begin to understand that we as a society are a big problem to our own future.

  7. Quintin Hansen said:

    I am a freashman safety managment student and interesteted in who’ll regulate and oversee these elctrons flying around? And can they keep things safe at a pace needed to overcome our energy needs?

  8. Texas Department Of Public Safety said:

    Nice read!. Your topic about What can the VC community do to help our energy crisis? needs more comments. I\’d like to spend me Sunday nights reading about texas department of public safety

  9. Yuanping Zhao said:

    I fully support Venrock’s idea on “More Miles Per Gallon”. Facing to the fact that 25% to
    30% engine efficiency, the whole world lacks
    feasible solution and technology until now:

    High Efficiency Integrated Heat Engine (HEIHE) is just invented and patented recently. HEIHE integrates multiple engine theory and practice into one engine body —— compound combustion, heterogeneous combustion, staged-combustion, combined cycles, multiple power strokes, multiple working fluids, multiple operation strokes and multiple engine efficiency contributors. HEIHE comprises twin compound cylinder structure, with the primary cylinder being the primary combustion and/or expansion cylinder; the secondary cylinder being the secondary combustion and/or expansion cylinder. Power strokes driven by expansions of different working fluids such as air-fuel combustion products and steam, as well as compressed air during pneumatic hybrid braking power regeneration mode, are integrated into one engine block. Twin cylinder structure provides the secondary compound expansions of three (3) different fluids as to harness the energies that would be lost with the fluid exhausts or during braking. All of these make HEIHE work around six (6) cycles with twelve (12) operation strokes. Among six (6) working cycles involved, four (4) cycles contain four (4) different power strokes but only one of the power strokes consumes the fuel. Thus the fuel conversion efficiency could be greatly increased, or even be doubled comparing with the conventional internal combustion engine (ICE). Its innovative engine structure has been posted at wfeast.com for comments and
    its prototyping funding supports.

    The inventor of this green engine is expect to see double fuel convention efficiency, thus
    double gas mileage, once it is implemented.
    Based on HEIHE architecture, 21st Century engine revolution is waving to us. I believe
    Venrock’s investment will definitely trig this
    engine revolution, making this innovative green
    engine a reality.

    HEIHE — Welcome to our energy hungery world!

  10. Dean W. Nelson said:

    The inevitable solution to the continued existence of mankind on our Earth
    resides in the entrepreneural availability of fusion power. As a simple unlearned
    Blog on this Planet, I am very curious to know whether Mr. Cagle’s, Skybolt™
    Fusion Reactor has any scientific validity, based upon your broad extensive
    Nuclear background as required?
    RE: Singularity Technologies, Inc.
    http://www.singtech.com/ FusionNow@singtech.com Dean Nelson

  11. molies said:

    it’s real energy future

Add a Comment