Amazon’s MP3 download service has moved up to be a strong number 2 competitor to Apple’s iTunes, according to a new report in USA Today. The service, which launched just six months ago, has becomes popular quickly thanks to its huge DRM-free library of digital music. This speaks to a larger issue Apple has had with its iTunes store recently: Failure to fulfill content promises Steve Jobs makes quite publicly.
Apple made headlines early last year with Steve Jobs’ memo posted to the company’s website calling for an end to DRM (digital rights management, the encryption that stops files from being copied and freely distributed). Shortly thereafter, music label EMI and Apple struck a deal to bring the EMI’s catalog of music to the iTunes store in a DRM-free format, which Apple dubbed “iTunes Plus”. By the time last year’s All Things D conference came around, Jobs stated, “Half of all the songs on iTunes will be available on iTunes Plus by the end of the year.”
The problem? We’re just about 4 month into 2008 and that still hasn’t come close to happening. Of the more than 6 million songs on iTunes, only around 2 million are available in DRM-free form. By comparison, every single track of the 4.5 million on AmazonMP3 is DRM-free. Apple only has the one major label (EMI) with DRM-free tracks; Amazon has all of the majors selling DRM-free music.
Is this all Steve Jobs’ fault? No, the music labels seem perfectly content to hold out on the digital music behemoth. Because iTunes controls around 80 percent of the digital music market, Jobs has been seen as having commanding power over the music industry. In the past, industry execs have asked Apple for new iTunes options such as flexible pricing only to have Jobs refuse. If AmazonMP3 keeps growing, it could be their leverage against Apple.
While the failure to meet the goal may not be Jobs’ fault, he still did make the statement. That, combined with his more recent failed promise of 1,000 digital movies available by the end of February for iTunes’ new movie rental store, suggests a problematic trend.
Apple was only able to produce somewhere between 400 and 500 of the promised 1,000 titles. It’s not as if Apple is narrowly missing these goals.
Apple’s customers (I’m a devout one myself) are notoriously loyal. Even after a few lackluster keynotes and a some botched launches (OS X Leopard, the Apple TV and the iPhone SDK were all delayed), the general mood around the company has remained positive. Jobs rewarded the patience with an excellent SDK event last month (our coverage). Apple’s stock is even now finally showing signs of recovering after taking a massive hit at the start of the year.
That said, if Jobs keeps failing to deliver on promises made for his company, at what point do we stop listening? A boy can only cry “wolf” so many times.
[Play the file below for more insight into the title.]
5 Comments
-
Luke G said:
Wait, is this math right? We’re 1/3 of the way into 2008, and Apple is 2/3 of the way to it’s 50% DRM-free goal…seems pretty doable to me.
-
MG Siegler said:
@Luke - Jobs made that comment at last year’s All Things D, meaning he promised 50% DRM free by the end of 2007. Something they missed by a long shot. Sorry if that was unclear.
-
william said:
I think that if you burn a cd of the music that you purchased on itunes that you can then play the music on another device.
If this is the case then the music you purchase from itunes is interoperable.
…..hmmmm….ipods, ipod touch, iphone….Thanks for the music Amazon…to bad you cant design a player
-
MG Siegler said:
@william - that is true, however most people - including steve jobs himself - know the future of music will involve the drm-free variety. it’s true that amazon has not made a great player such as the iPod, but because their music is all 100% drm-free mp3s it can play on any players such as the ones you mention.
-
Isaac N said:
Is Amazon really # 2 after iTunes? I have seen some debate around this story, because the USA Today story didn’t cite any real sales or market share figures. Also, eMusic, a site that’s been selling MP3s for as long as I can remember, is disputing it: http://www.17dots.com/ It is amazing that USA Today would overlook a site like eMusic which obviously has a dedicated following, just because it only sells indie music!
6 Trackbacks
5:06 pm
MySpace Music days away from an assault on iTunes » VentureBeat said:
[...] delivering DRM-free music to iTunes while giving it to AmazonMP3 may be helping that service grow (our coverage). MySpace Music could well be an attack on another [...]
3:39 pm
Amid the coronation of iTunes as digital music king, the sound of war » VentureBeat said:
[...] has said this will be the future of the industry, yet iTunes is failing to deliver on this promise (our coverage). AmazonMP3 has all of the major labels providing DRM-free tracks, while MySpace Music already has [...]
1:10 am
Apple, movie studios realize people want new releases when they’re new » VentureBeat said:
[...] is an important step in the shift to digital film distribution. It should help erase doubts about Apple competing in the movie business as it has in the music business. Now, if only iTunes would implement a rent-before-you-buy system. [...]
11:14 pm
Mobile music to play a key role in the 3G iPhone? » VentureBeat said:
[...] As has been very clear, Apple does not cave in very easily. Many of the labels are still apparently holding back on giving iTunes the same DRM-free music that they give to other services such as AmazonMP3 — another move seen as a negotiating tactic. But rather than give the labels the upper-hand, Apple has sat back and let promises go unfulfilled. [...]
9:15 pm
Two weeks until Apple’s WWDC event: Some keynote wild card options » VentureBeat said:
[...] Apple is failing behind other services in terms of its DRM-free music availability, quality and its pricing isn’t even the best at all times anymore. This combined with all the pressure it’s getting from rivals for its video content on iTunes (see above with the Apple TV), means iTunes itself could be in for a major shakeup soon. [...]
11:33 am
Five billion iTunes songs sold. One looming problem: AmazonMP3 is better » VentureBeat said:
[...] all accounts, iTunes is still nowhere near the promise Steve Jobs made at the All Things D conference last year that half of all the songs on iTunes would be DRM-free by [...]