storm_clouds040108.pngDespite a one-day rise in the stock market, the macro-economic outlook is stormy, and confidence is falling among venture capitalists and entrepreneurs.

Last fall’s housing slowdown has led to turmoil among Wall Street banks. Private equity firms can’t borrow as much money to hatch their takeovers. Stock market have dropped, with the Nasdaq off 15 percent since the start of the year. Since public companies are under the gun they aren’t buying.

Successful venture exits are becoming scarce. Yesterday, the National Venture Capital Association reported the first quarter saw only five venture-backed initial public offerings worth $282.73 million, down dramatically from 31 IPOs worth $3.04 billion in the fourth quarter. Mergers and acquisitions are also on the decline, with just 56 in the first quarter compared to 83 in the fourth quarter.

At the same time, angel investors have become more cautious because of the economic volatility, according to the 2007 Angel Market Analysis released Tuesday by the Center for Venture Research at the University of New Hampshire. That’s significant because angels account for 39 percent of investments in seed-stage start-ups.

What’s more, the Silicon Valley Venture Capitalist Confidence Index, an index that tracks the confidence among venture investors, fell to its lowest level in the past four years in the fourth quarter of 2007. You can expect that this confidence fell further in the first quarter, with the collapse of Wall Street bank Bear Stearns earlier this month.

There is still reason to deny that start-ups will be impacted. Swift action by the Fed, a stimulus package that gives consumers some spending money, and sweeping regulatory changes could restore some confidence. Startups getting funding now can fly over the storm, since they won’t be selling their products for a couple of years.

“I’m fairly bullish,” said Jason Green, a partner at Emergence Capital. “The broader economy is tough for consumers. But I’m not seeing signs of change in valuations of start-ups.”

But it’s time to check out contingency plans. Deepak Kamra, a partner at Canaan Partners, said, “Companies that are built on having lots of users but no real revenues won’t last. That all changes with the downturn.”

More companies are drawing down tranches on previously raised rounds. “Smart companies are battening down the hatches now,” said Thomas Cole, a partner at Trinity Ventures. “If they can raise more money, they will. That’s like putting more gas in the tank.”

International markets are still going strong. You can expect start-ups and venture investing overseas to pick up steam. And there is a chance that private equity groups spawned from oil money could still fuel a lot of M&A ahead.

Some entrepreneurs say a recession is a great time to start a company. Cheap employees are plentiful and other kinds of costs are down.

But you can’t look at the glass as half full if market conditions continue to deteriorate. “At some point, you have to realize that when times are bad, they’re bad for everyone,” said Ryan Floyd, a partner at Storm Ventures.

Everyone agrees quality start-ups should continue to get funding and the broader woes will instill discipline among both start-ups and VCs.

And some innovation trends are so strong they will power through a recession. The forces opening up the mobile markets will also likely overpower economic trends. Consumers should benefit from the growth of third-party applications on the iPhone, the opening of Verizon Wireless’ closed network, and the expected arrival of Google’s Android open cell phone platform.

“We’re still seeing a lot of outstanding early stage deals today and so from that standpoint, my confidence is high,” Floyd said. “If you want an exit in 2008, it’s pretty bleak.” snagnvca.jpg

(Photo via Ioan Nicolae)

Trackback URL

12 Trackbacks

  1. April 2nd, 2008
    7:50 am

    The “whatchamcallit” post recession phase transition « please mr editor…. said:

    [...] on current funding, or exit on the best available terms. Updating that, I would say that the funding window is closing fast. By that I mean that, very few new ideas from new entrepreneurs will get funded and even most [...]

  2. April 2nd, 2008
    8:38 am

    StartupNewz.com said:

    VCs slowing down?…

    Inspite of a one-day sunshine and smiles in Wall Street that the economic woes are over, it appears that the VCs are heading for the cellars and things do not look good for the startup community. This is what Dean Takahashi is investigating and talkin…

  3. April 2nd, 2008
    5:56 pm

    More rough data on venture exits last quarter, opportunities are early and elsewhere » VentureBeat said:

    [...] Thomson Financial. The number of exits are dropping because of larger issues in the US economy, we discussed in this article yesterday. Public companies become more conservative about buying private companies. The private companies [...]

  4. April 2nd, 2008
    10:10 pm

    Don’t Batten Down The Hatches on a Shit Business : The Drama 2.0 Show said:

    [...] landscape become apparent to even the completely most uninitiated, more venture capitalists are recognizing that tougher times lie [...]

  5. April 3rd, 2008
    2:48 am

    The credit crunch is starting to make itself felt in venture capital « The Equity Kicker said:

    [...] startup. I recommend reading the whole post, but the best summary is below, and is originally from VentureBeat: Successful venture exits are becoming scarce. Yesterday, the National Venture Capital Association [...]

  6. April 3rd, 2008
    2:15 pm

    Bankruptcy Blog › Venture Capitalists Are Feeling It Too: said:

    [...] Some venture investors heading for the cellars, as larger economic problems loom » VentureBeat Some venture investors heading for the cellars, as larger economic problems loom Share This: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages. [...]

  7. April 3rd, 2008
    9:04 pm

    Short Notes: Zapak, online ads, Twitterlocal « Blue Screen Of Duds said:

    [...] Liew, meanwhile, posts a good short one on Andrew Chen’s take on forecasting sales for web start ups. Both are good reads irrespective of whether you are a start up or [...]

  8. April 7th, 2008
    3:12 am

    SKMurphy » Recession Requires A Focus on Revenue said:

    [...] stop needing customer development. And, although fewer folks may decide to quit their jobs to raise VC funds, some may still choose to launch a consulting career or a software startup and discover the need [...]

  9. New survey: VCs feel glum (but not too glum) about the economy » VentureBeat said:

    [...] been writing quite a bit about the different ways the downturn is hitting the startup world — this overview, for example, touches on declining public offerings, fewer acquisitions and a lack of VC [...]

  10. It’s official: Venture investment declined in Q1 » VentureBeat said:

    [...] continue to hurt venture investment is the decreasing number of IPOs — according to the NVCA, there were only five IPOs during the first quarter of 2008. The acquisition market is weakening too, Saberi said, which is putting downward pressure on [...]

  11. As vc’s head for cellar, startups should head for garage! : Texas Startup Blog said:

    [...] is reporting, what many of you have been thinking, “venture investors are heading for cellars, as larger economic problems loom.“  Dean Takahashi explains, Last fall’s housing slowdown has led to turmoil among Wall [...]

  12. Amid turmoil and news of $700B federal bailout, is the sky falling for venture capitalists and start-ups? » VentureBeat said:

    [...] situation is more volatile than the last time we did this, during the Bear Sterns financial crisis this spring. The world markets are hanging in the balance. Fred Wilson, blogger and partner at Union Square [...]

7 Comments

  1. April 2nd, 2008
    8:00 am

    Yakov said:

    The inventors need to turn to developing markets that have become the major drivers of economic growth.

  2. April 2nd, 2008
    8:50 am

    dave mcclure said:

    public market activity has less & less impact on startups & (early-stage) VCs, which are more & more driven by acquisitions. fear & greed are correlated in all markets, however for the most part larger company dealmaking isn’t based on IPOs or even debt market liquidity. there is an impact if Internet-based advertising & ecommerce experiences pullbacks due to consumer or business recessions, but the overall growth of the online market combined with offline->online budgeting transitions likely offset mostarket downturns, or at least certainly over the long run.

    if anything the recent trend has been towards more platform opportunities & new ways to make money, not less. potential consolidation of Msft-yhoo notwithstanding, there are more large companies making money on the internt than ever, and they should continue to see benefit in buying new tech & products from smaller startups to rollout to yheir customers.

    in any case, startups that are innovative, prudent, and can generate revenue should do alright. and last time I checked there was no recession in innovation.

  3. April 2nd, 2008
    8:57 am

    dave mcclure said:

    dean: I really take issue with your survey options. only providing “bad” & “worse” options is stacking the deck with negative sentiment that only reinforces the pessimistic slant of the article. you’re leading the witness.

    I really think a more balanced set of choices should be provided, if you’re trying to solicit community opinion. perhaps some of us valley angels be entrepreneurs are a bit more optimistic than the traditional VC community.

    my $.02,

  4. April 2nd, 2008
    8:16 pm

    CubQuiege said:

    Hello. Let’s get acquainted!
    My name is Jessika.

  5. April 2nd, 2008
    8:34 pm

    Peter said:

    Dave:

    Your assertion “public market activity has less & less impact on startups & (early-stage) VCs, which are more & more driven by acquisitions” is fundamentally flawed, both logically and empirically.

    Favorable M&A activity (defined as exits at a multiple of paid-in capital, not a discount of paid-in capital) is positively correlated with the public market indices. It is obvious why. When companies have more currency, they spend it on M&A. So, early stage VC valuations absolutely *are* impacted by public market activity, but the impact lags the public market. Don’t believe anyone is immune to the wealth effects of prosperity or the adverse effects of decreasing equity values. All markets are linked. Economics 101.

  6. April 6th, 2008
    11:08 pm

    shuaben said:

    We can not expect larege or many deals this year, whatever in America or China

  7. April 8th, 2008
    9:41 am

    Sam said:

    At the end of the day, it is the marginal ideas or businesses with ambiguous revenue models that will have a tough time competing for investment dollars.

Add a Comment