MySpace, then Facebook and then Google all recently launched services for third parties to access their users’ data through other sites.
Google, though, uses Facebook’s developer platform to distribute Facebook user data through its own service, Google Friend Connect. Now, Facebook has cut off that access.
When Google announced Friend Connect on Monday, I asked the company for clarification on its relationship with Facebook — strangely, Google didn’t offer MySpace data even though those two companies are partners on Open Social. A main point of the announcement, after all, was that Open Social applications could run on other sites, with better access to social networks’ data.
Instead, Google announced that third party developers would be able to access data from Orkut, smaller Open Social member network hi5 and Linked — and Facebook. Google, it seems, wanted to see just how open Facebook’ social network rival was.
For Google’s response to my question, check out this audio clip. As the company tells me in the clip, it has no business relationship with Facebook.
From the Facebook company blog, today:
In the past, when we found applications passing user data to another party (for instance, to ad networks for the purpose of targeting), we suspended those applications and worked with those developers to ensure they respect user privacy. Now that Google has launched Friend Connect, we’ve had a chance to evaluate the technology. We’ve found that it redistributes user information from Facebook to other developers without users’ knowledge, which doesn’t respect the privacy standards our users have come to expect and is a violation of our Terms of Service. Just as we’ve been forced to do for other applications that redistribute data in a way users might not expect or understand, we’ve had to suspend Friend Connect’s access to Facebook user information until it comes into compliance. We’ve reached out to Google several times about this issue, and hope to work with them to enable users to share their data exactly when and where they choose.
Tags: co:Facebook, co:google
1:06 pm
By Open They Really Mean Closed - GigaOM said:
[...] 08Archives By Open They Really Mean Closed — This is hilarious. Google and Facebook trying to out anti-open each [...]
2:01 pm
Mark Cuban’s Simple Plan to Unseat Google Won’t Work « SmoothSpan Blog said:
[...] want Google to have access to various aspects for various reasons. I agree with Om Malik, this one is hilarious. Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Google’s Paid Click Rates: Google Needs the [...]
1:12 am
By Open They Really Mean Closed | DougsTech.com - Tech News, Reviews, and Guides said:
[...] This is hilarious. Google ignores MySpace. Facebook blocks Google’s Friend Connect. Now that Google has launched Friend Connect, we’ve had a chance to evaluate the technology. We’ve found that it redistributes user information from Facebook to other developers without users’ knowledge, which doesn’t respect the privacy standards our users have come to expect and is a violation of our Terms of Service. [...]
2:05 am
Facebook disconnects from Friend Connect said:
[...] comply with its privacy guidelines and decided to bail out (for now anyway). Turns out, according to Venturebeat, that Google has no business relationship with Facebook and included FB data on its [...]
2:42 am
Google en Facebook zijn geen vriendjes | Wilcootje.nl said:
[...] Orkut, Plaxo en Google Talk worden geïmporteerd. Facebook wil dat niet en heeft Friend Connect geblokkeerd. Niet toevallig: Facebook biedt site-eigenaren sinds vorige week een vergelijkbare dienst. Net als [...]
4:21 am
Six Clicks Volume II | Webfact said:
[...] the Full Article: LINK VI Type: 6clicks a2a_linkname=”Six Clicks Volume [...]
4:48 pm
CHIUSI E ASOCIALI « os3ga said:
[...] nell’elenco dei network mashabili. E infatti sono bastati pochi giorni perche’ Facebook impedisse a GFC di prelevare dati dal proprio network appellandosi a ragioni di privacy dei propri utenti. [...]
11:20 am
Powder keg or conjecture? Microsoft buying Facebook could start Internet War I » VentureBeat said:
[...] but with such a deal, that battle could take the forefront. Facebook and Google are already bickering over how data portability should be handled, just imagine if Microsoft gets into the same fight with Google. It’s easy if you [...]
11:05 am
Facebook Platform to go open source — but how open? » VentureBeat said:
[...] has been sending out mixed signals on how open it wants to be — it caused a bit of an Internet brouhaha after cutting off Google’s Friend Connect, but it also just announced a feature called Facebook Connect, which allows users to access their [...]
3:38 pm
A social graph discussion breaks out at a legal fight » VentureBeat said:
[...] month, Facebook cut off access to Google’s Friend Connect. The social network claimed Google’s service was pulling Facebook user data without the [...]
12:46 pm
Should people in glass Facebook offices throw stones? » VentureBeat said:
[...] This openess debate is being played out on many fronts, but perhaps none more high-profile than Facebook versus Google. It’s pretty clear that Google feels its Open Social platform is much more open than Facebook’s, and the two sides recently came to blows when Facebook cut off Google’s Friend Connect from accessing its data. [...]
11:51 am
ReputationDefender Blog : Facebook Decides Not To Connect Friends With Google said:
[...] recently caught wind of this VentureBeat post that deals with Online Identity Management and Internet Privacy [...]