Are Apple and AT&T failing on iPhone activation?

Updated

It looks like Apple has hit some serious problems with the U.S. launch of the iPhone 3G. I just left the crowd outside the Apple Store in downtown San Francisco, where the first person in line — Dale Larson, a mobile consultant who has been camping out since Wednesday night — came out of the store reporting that he couldn’t activate the phone, and that Apple stores across the country have the same problem.

A few minutes later, another customer came out, having apparently purchased an iPhone successfully, but without activating. Due to technical problems, it sounded like Apple was scrapping its plans for in-store activation of the required AT&T plans. However, my roommate Tony Tulathimutte tells me he’s in line right now, and Apple is activating phones again. I’m still trying to find out the latest news but until then here are two videos that we recorded through Qik. The first shows Larson explaining his problems to the press, noting specifically that without the in-store activation, last year’s iPhone launch went much more smoothly. Unfortunately, the sound is terrible, so you may have to just imagine what he’s saying. Sorry. The second shows members of the VentureBeat crew, including Tony, writer MG Siegler and business manager Jacob Mullins entering the Apple store shortly after I left.

Update: As noted by our first commenter and other sites, Apple is having problems with downloads of the new iTunes version 7.7, which includes the iPhone App Store, and of the iPhone firmware. That means first generation iPhones that update today are being “bricked,” i.e. rendered nonfunctional. There are also reports from other Apple stores that Apple is letting people buy their iPhones without activation, although I hear that activation is working now.

Update 2: MG Siegler here. Just got back from the “frontline” aka the Apple Store. I can assure you, the iPhone activation process is still not working. I have an iPhone 3G in my hand, the only problem? It’s not activated.

Update 3: Anthony again. Because I’m sure everyone was wondering, I did indeed decide to break my one-day iPhone boycott. I went out this morning just to enjoy the vibe and help give out donuts and coffee (we beat Apple to the refreshment-distribution punch by an hour or so, by the way), but the excitement convinced me that I had to make the leap now. All the problems sure killed the buzz, though, and I figured I couldn’t take the whole morning off. Tomorrow it is.

Anyway, keep an eye out for MG’s more comprehensive post on Apple’s difficulties coming soon (here), plus more coverage — including photos of the team in brand-new VentureBeat T-shirts — later in the day.

Next Story: MobileBeat additions: Nokia’s Mike Baker, Blackberry Fund’s Rick Segal
Previous Story: Where to buy your iPhone

Bookmark and Share

Tags: ,

Photo of Anthony Ha

About the Author, Anthony Ha

Anthony is VentureBeat's assistant editor, as well as its reporter on enterprise technology, cloud computing, and tech policy. Before joining VentureBeat in 2008, Anthony worked at the Hollister Free Lance, where he won awards from the California Newspaper Publishers Association for breaking news coverage and writing. He attended Stanford University and now lives in San Francisco. Reach him at anthony@venturebeat.com. You can also follow Anthony on Twitter.

  • It gets worse.

    For old-style iPhone folks, updates are failing... My phone is non-functional right now and iTunes is timing out. I'd sure love to be able to make a phone call.
  • Aymerik
    I had a similar problem earlier this morning, but refreshing the iTunes Store a few times finally resolved it. Once iTunes was able to connect to their server, the rest of the upgrade went fine. They're basically getting overloaded on the server side, between all the folks upgrading, and all the new activations.
  • Yep, I have a conversation on video with someone on that issue this morning, will get it up soon. Thanks.
  • Yep, I've heard from three people in the same boat as webrwright so far. They updated the firmware for their old phones and then couldn't activate and for now have a brick.
  • Sandy
    Yeah my "classic" iPhone was bricked for a few hours...left it plugged in to my laptop trying to connect to iTunes...went to lunch, came back and it was in the middle of the restore phase of the software update...all is well now...(quite annoying however)
  • Does anyone have any word on whether the activation server (usually run by the carrier) is controlled by Apple or AT&T?

    My understanding of the process is when you plug the phone into the cradle and it does the "activation checking/setup" step, it's connecting to the carriers authorization servers to register the radio serial number on their system.

    So the downtime is AT&T's fault (again!).
  • frustrated
    I'm so glad major companies can keep up with the consumers. I have the original iPhone, downloaded the update no problem, but have been waiting 3, yes 3, hours now trying to get to phone to come back to life. I am so frustrated with Apple and AT&T right now. Its a good thing I'm not a doctor!!
  • it's still not 100% clear but i have some expanded thoughts on the situation here http://venturebeat.com/2008/07/11/the-great-iph...
  • Stu
    Hilarious. And people wonder why Apple can't make a dent in the corporate marketplace...
  • Rodman
    I think that this has been a lucky day for me. I stood in line at a local AT&T store this morning and after a relatively short 4 hour wait, I was the proud owner of the new iphone. The AT&T rep told me that I would have to activate the phone once I got home, through iTunes. Once I got home I quickly connected my phone to iTunes and ran into the same "network" problem that everyone else has written about. After 2 hours of trying, I finally got through and my phone is now activated. I am in California so I hope that my ability to activate my phone is an indication that the iphone activation process is getting better in the Eastern and Central time zones.
  • Yeah, let's hope so.
  • Mac_browncoat
    Updated my old iphone to new version this am with no troubles! Loaded lots of new apps too! Hope it goes as smoother for others today.