TheFunded, a site that lets entrepreneurs rate venture capitalists, continues to stir things up.
EDF Ventures, a mid-sized venture capital fund in Ann Arbor, Michigan which has been reviewed negatively by several people at the site, has subpoenaed some records from TheFunded in a court action the firm is taking against an entrepreneur who left a comment.
As you’ll see below, the anonymous entrepreneur said the firm’s members “are to be avoided unless you are desperate.”
The retaliation is apparently an attempt to silence the entrepreneur, a trend at TheFunded we’ve written about before.
Previously, we also reported about a cease and desist letter sent to TheFunded by a debt firm, Hercules, but under the Communications Decency Act, TheFunded’s site doesn’t have liability for the comments left by third-parties at the site, and Hercules dropped its demands. Something similar happened with a lawyer tried to sue Avvo, a site that lets people comment on lawyers. The lawyer failed in his efforts. Now we’re seeing EDF go directly after the entrepreneur, which is a first.
A copy of the subpoena is below. I’ve also included a screenshot of TheFunded’s review page about EDF, the firm that is taking the legal action, where you’ll see the offending comment at bottom. EDM is apparently the parent company of the fund.
In a statement, Adeo Ressi, chief executive of TheFunded, vowed the action would fail, because he doesn’t store records about the identity of commenters. He said this should help the site even more, because it will encourage entrepreneurs to come forward and leave more comments:
When TheFunded was conceived, we understood that some investors might attempt to take legal action against the views of entrepreneurs. In order to prevent this form of censorship, TheFunded has been carefully designed and takes extensive measures to protect the anonymity all those who share their opinions on the fundraising experience. TheFunded does not store IP addresses, email addresses, or any other personal information associated with a Member account in any database or any file system operated by the company.
For every CEO that shares an experience, there are nine others who are hesitant. The worst stories of investor abuse remain untold, and TheFunded hopes that this test of Member anonymity will help open up floodgate.
[Disclosure: VentureBeat has a business relationship with TheFunded, including links to each other's sites]
1:17 am
Venture fund tries to sue entrepreneur who left negative comment on The Funded - bad idea | The Equity Kicker said:
[...] reported yesterday that venture firm EDF is attempting to take legal action against an entrepreneur who left [...]
5:11 am
The Funded sued for the Identity of John Doe — TechWag said:
[...] Venture Beat and Techcruch cover some of this and the comment at both sites about how the Funded runs their [...]
1:55 pm
Squawk Box August 13 — Alec Saunders SquawkBox said:
[...] TheFunded.com is getting sued by EDF Ventures. Is this TheFunded’s watershed moment? Well, it’s not the first time they’ve been challenged and probably won’t be the last. We were treated to a short discussion of press sourcing rules and libel laws by Andy Abramson as well. [...]
3:36 pm
Trying To Sue Somoene Who Criticizes You Isn’t The Best Way To Boost Your Reputation | My Best Blogroll said:
[...] sue the VC ratings site, TheFunded.com, another VC firm, EDF Ventures in Ann Arbor, Michigan, has sent a subpoena to the site to try to identify a critical commenter. This is, of course, the exact wrong response. First off, TheFunded doesn’t keep records of who [...]
5:12 pm
Trying To Sue Somoene Who Criticizes You Isn’t The Best Way To Boost Your Reputation | Technology | Daily Blog & News said:
[...] And here we go again. Less than a year after a venture capital firm tried to sue the VC ratings site, TheFunded.com, another VC firm, EDF Ventures in Ann Arbor, Michigan, has sent a subpoena to the site to try to identify a critical commenter. [...]
6:13 pm
HipMojo.com » Free Legal and PR Advice to EDF: Don’t be a Douchebag said:
[...] Read more. [...]
7:22 pm
TheFunded inspires lawsuit from VC firm | Daily Technology News said:
[...] VentureBeat first reported the story. [...]
8:50 pm
Trying To Keep The Information Train In The Station Doesn’t Work said:
[...] that this isn’t necessarily the case. This has been made more than apparent with the current legal action against TheFunded.com by EDF Ventures as they sue for the identity of one of the site members. Another example came this past weekend, [...]
9:07 pm
Trying To Keep The Information Train In The Station Doesn’t Work | World News said:
[...] that this isn’t necessarily the case. This has been made more than apparent with the current legal action against TheFunded.com by EDF Ventures as they sue for the identity of one of the site members. Another example came this past weekend, [...]
9:36 pm
Trying To Keep The Information Train In The Station Doesn’t Work »TechAddress said:
[...] that this isn’t necessarily the case. This has been made more than apparent with the current legal action against TheFunded.com by EDF Ventures as they sue for the identity of one of the site members. Another example came this past weekend, [...]
2:30 am
Legal News. Appellate Court rules Open Source license violations can be treated as copyright infringment in case between Jacobsen and Katzer. The Funded Gets Subpoena » Metue said:
[...] In other amusing legal news… Venture Capital firm review website The Funded has reportedly been served with a subpoena as part of a Michigan defamation suit. [...]
3:25 am
News » Trying To Sue Someone Who Criticizes You Isn’t The Best Way To Boost Your Reputation said:
[...] And here we go again. Less than a year after a venture capital firm tried to sue the VC ratings site, TheFunded.com, another VC firm, EDF Ventures in Ann Arbor, Michigan, has sent a subpoena to the site to try to identify a critical commenter. [...]
7:30 am
Ann Arbor VC Firm, EDF Ventures Sends Subpoena To Find Out Negative Anonymous User On The Funded said:
[...] Below is a copy of the subpoena that I found via VentureBeat: [...]
12:33 am
Subpoenaed documents at TheFunded reveal more negative commentary about EDF Ventures » VentureBeat said:
[...] capital firm EDF Ventures last week subpoenaed the Web site TheFunded, demanding information about a person who left negative comments about [...]
8:34 am
Business Never End | Business and Technology » Subpoenaed documents at TheFunded reveal more negative commentary about EDF Ventures said:
[...] capital firm EDF Ventures last week subpoenaed the Web site TheFunded, demanding information about a person who left negative comments about [...]
6:10 pm
TheFunded delivers subpoenaed documents » VentureBeat said:
[...] the VC-review site that was recently subponaed by EDF Ventures, says it has handed over the requested documents — and, amusingly, site owner [...]
2:23 pm
Trying To Keep The Information Train In The Station Doesn’t Work | Social Media News Desk said:
[...] that this isn’t necessarily the case. This has been made more than apparent with the current legal action against TheFunded.com by EDF Ventures as they sue for the identity of one of the site members. Another example came this past weekend, [...]