GamesBeat

Three gamers respond to Microsoft’s ever-changing Xbox One policies

Above: The controller for the upcoming Xbox One console.

This post has been edited by the GamesBeat staff. Opinions by GamesBeat community writers do not necessarily reflect those of the staff.
Editor's Note from Stephanie Carmichael:
While some gamers think Microsoft is listening to its audience by changing its policies with the Xbox One, others believe the company has made too many early mistakes and shown too much disrespect to fully recover. These feelings will undoubtedly influences purchasing decisions, and that's what Cassie seeks to uncover by interviewing three different gamers. Will they put their money down on the Xbox One, or will the PlayStation 4 come out stronger?

It’s hard to keep up with all of the changes Microsoft has made to its policies for the Xbox One. Not so long ago, it said that owners would need an Internet connection just to play a game and would need to have the Kinect plugged in at all times to run the console. It also planned to introduce a brand new way to share games that the gaming community didn’t seem ready for. Now all of that has changed.

Gamers have reacted in many different ways to these policy reversals, and it seems that Microsoft is going to have a hard time convincing people that the Xbox One is better off.

I interviewed three gamers — Andrew Semicek, the founder of wethenerdy.com; Ryan Gross, an Xbox 360 loyalist; and Evan Podlaseck, the co-founder of PXLpushers on YouTube — to get their opinions on the Xbox One.


When you first saw the Xbox One announcement at Microsoft’s press conference earlier this year, knowing the price point, required Internet connection, and the new policy on sharing games with friends and family, did you think you would be buying an Xbox One?

Andrew Semicek: No, I did not. All but the family sharing plan turned me off immediately.

Ryan Gross: No, I wouldn’t have batted an eye over the Xbox One. The idea of sharing games with several people is awesome, but it upset me with how they treated their customers. I’m not a military man by any means, but to tell the armed forces that you’re stuck with the 360 and act snug about it? That’s poor representation as a company.

Evan Podlaseck: I knew from the start that I wasn’t buying an Xbox One, and that’s coming from an Xbox 360 fan. The Xbox One is no longer a gaming system; it’s a TV box that sometimes plays games. Some of the features were cool, but it seemed like they didn’t trust their customers anymore.

Did Microsoft’s press conference at the Electronic Entertainment Expo a few months later change your opinions on the Xbox One and your decision whether to purchase one or not?

Semicek: No, it solidified my decision. After the off-handed comments Don Mattrick made about the Xbox One, I decided that if I were to purchase any new console moving forward, it would be PlayStation 4.

Gross: No, because if it weren’t for Microsoft being obnoxious, I might’ve considered it. Let’s face it: Broke college students can’t drop $60 on a single game, and they offered a way to cope. However, they ruined that. Now since they’re reverting back to the physical disc policy, I don’t see a reason to ever go with Xbox again. I won’t be buying a PS4, either. There isn’t enough support for it to be considered as a worthwhile investment, in my opinion.

Podlaseck: It improved the image a bit, but it still didn’t convince me to buy an Xbox One. Some of the games looked good, but they didn’t sell me on them.

It seems that, even though Microsoft has changed a lot of its policies, gamers aren’t being very forgiving. Do you think Microsoft lost some of their fanbase that they cannot get back?

Semicek: I think they lost a large amount of their fanbase, namely armed forces who have no Internet access to use and many of which played 360 to relax.

Gross: As a Redditor [Reddit is a well-known online community], when they dropped the news about the Xbox One and its always-on policy, PS4 memes went rampant. Even now, people are leery, and I know some people who’ll get the system, but it’s because they’re stuck with their Xbox-exclusive first-person shooters like Halo.

Podlaseck: Oh yeah, definitely. They lost me, which is saying a lot. I don’t disagree with the used game policy. I just don’t think it was the right time to implement something like that. They lost a lot of their fanbase because they were rude to their customers.

The Kinect is now optional, but it will still come bundled with the system. Do you think this is going to steer some people away from the console if they aren’t interested in the Kinect?

Semicek: Yeah, I think so. By adding the additional $100 price to the console, it will hurt early adopters when PCs are already higher powered and actually cheaper now.

Gross: Not really. The R.O.B. came with the NES to make it seem more like a toy than a video game after the arcade market crashed. I think it makes Microsoft’s purpose unclear, though. I don’t want a DVR; I want a mostly dedicated console.

Podlaseck: If they announce there will be an Xbox One with no Kinect, I might strongly consider buying one, especially if it goes down to $400. Even though you might not use it for games, people will use it for a lot of the other TV-related stuff. A lot of gamers say they don’t like Kinect, but I think Kinect is underutilized a lot. I want to see Kinect utilized for games, such as in Mass Effect 3, where you can shout out voice commands. I want to see more of that.

At the end of the day, after all of these policy changes, do you, today, plan on buying an Xbox One at launch? Why or why not?

Semicek: I do not. For $400, it’s too expensive for me in my current state. Also, none of the launch titles look like they will blow me away.

Gross: No. Microsoft is assuming that people will buy their console regardless of how they act. That is not the case. They only changed policies because of a public outcry, resulting in PS4 preorders beating them tremendously. I, however, will not be buying a PS4. There isn’t enough support for it to be considered, in my opinion, a worthwhile investment.

Podlaseck: As of right now, no. I will keep my 360. I’m going to do my best to pay for my PS4 without selling my 360. It’s not just about policy stuff. It’s about PlayStation trusting their customers and Microsoft doing the opposite. I think PS4 could lead in the next console race for a while. A lot of their games looked better and more innovative. I plan on getting an Xbox One eventually, but not at launch.


So there you have it. All three of these gamers were not won over by Microsoft even though the company reversed the policies that most people were upset about. If you’d like to see some more responses, check out part two here.

Do you plan on purchasing an Xbox One at launch? Have the policies regarding the system changed your mind about purchasing one? Let me know in the comments below.


Screen Shot 2014-03-25 at 2.00.11 PMGamesBeat 2014 — VentureBeat’s sixth annual event on disruption in the video game market — is coming up on Sept 15-16 in San Francisco. Purchase one of the first 50 tickets and save $400!
0 comments

GamesBeat is your source for gaming news and reviews. But it's also home to the best articles from gamers, developers, and other folks outside of the traditional press. Register or log in to join our community of writers. You can even make a few bucks publishing stories here! Learn more.

You are now an esteemed member of the GamesBeat community. That means you can comment on stories or post your own to GB Unfiltered (look for the "New Post" link by mousing over your name in the red bar up top). But first, why don't you fill out your via your ?

About GamesBeat