GamesBeat

‘Salon.com’ really needs to stop publishing articles about video games

This post has not been edited by the GamesBeat staff. Opinions by GamesBeat community writers do not necessarily reflect those of the staff.

For anyone lucky enough not to have stumbled onto Salon.com, it is an online liberal publication that specializes in giving any Berkeley educated radical or sorry excuse of a failure the opportunity to cry about social and political issues that no one cares about (regardless of your political stance). Checkout their Facebook page and you’re guaranteed to find articles with smart-ass comments ripping on the idiotic subject or the classic response of, “Nobody gives a f***“.

So to no surprise they have published several ill-written articles that have been very critical of the video game industry and culture. However unlike their typical cry baby banter; none of the writers could be considered experts because most of them admit to not having actually played or know anything about the video games they are discussing. Worse is that on several occasions they have published articles that reinforce the junk science that video games makes the player violent (a myth disproved by countless studies).

To be clear; I do not see myself as a conservative and I’m definitely not affiliated with some Tea Party radical group. I’m also well-educated enough to know that games like Call of Duty and Battlefield are also works of propaganda used to glorify the military, but they’re fun to play. However as a gamer I cannot silently sit aside while Salon.com gives a voice to fake gamers who are pretending to have deep insight while slandering our gaming community.

The best example to look at is My fantasies of mass murder by Brian McGuigan, which attempts to reinforce the junk science that video games turns people into violent killers using the author’s pathetic life story as an example. The author tells the story of his anti-social youth (the typical Emo kid stuff) along with how he tried to escape his problems with video games only to have fantasies of wanting to kill people. While Salon.com had approved any comment that kissed up to the author, its Facebook page was stuffed with users calling the author out on his BS.

Another to look at is Gamers, stop supporting violence! by Rohan Talbot; a diatribe that violent video games makes us accept violence while trying to reinforce the junk science in a subtle but smug manner. The sub-headline gives the illusion that it’s  going to be another diatribe on how video games are tools used by the right-wing media but instead Talbot makes a poor argument denouncing the violence in video games while admitting to never having played a Call of Duty game (which he describes as being all about killing foreigners) or having an interest in playing Grand Theft Auto V. In the end he suggest that gamers should play more games that focus on “sensitivity”.

Video games make us all losers! became a very popular punching bag among real gamers after Jesper Juul refereed to modern video games as an artistic tragedy because the players dies repeatedly. It was not the critical look that killed his credibility but referring to modern games as, “This casual revolution in video games is forcing us to rethink the role of failure in games: should all games be intense personal struggles that bombard the player with constant failures and frequent setbacks, or can games be more relaxed experiences, like a walk in the park? ” Basically he is saying that games today are too hard and need to be made easy to appease the casual gamer audience (despite the fact that game industry has been dumbing down games just to appeal to casual gamer).

Of course being a liberal publication pandering to radical-liberals, its going to publish a few articles that accuses video games of having right-wing propaganda or promoting racism and sexism with little to no real evidence.

“Grand Theft Auto” maker: Video games hate liberals by Jon Hochschartner is a half-ass attempt to depict Red Dead Redemption and L.A. Noire of having a right-wing bias using the most flimsy of evidence. According to Hochschartner; the Mexican Revolution part of Red Dead Redemption is depicted of having an anti-government message as it pits a brutal Mexican warlord against rebels lead by an opportunist. Meanwhile; LA Noire has an anti-liberal message because one of the suspects in the “The Gas Man” case is a communist.

Yup; that was Hochschatner’s entire argument boiled down to only two sentences. But to call this diatribe an “argument” would be an insult to the classic art of public discussion and rational reasoning. Unfortunately he tries again with  “The Legend of Zelda” is classist, sexist and racist (yeah you real all that correctly) only to copy & paste someone else’s theory then reinforcing it with his own opinion by using the most flimsy of evidence.

For most Salon.com contributors to discuss about the cultural and social impacts of  video games is the equivalent of some Tea Party congressmen discussing the “economical benefits” of cutting funds for social programs. If Salon.com really wants to discuss the social and cultural aspects of video games then they need to find a writer who is also a game, not some Berkeley educated radical. Until then they should just stick to articles about social and political issues that no one cares about or “This is what Rush Limbaugh said today” banter.


Mobile developer or publisher? VentureBeat is studying mobile marketing automation. Fill out our 5-minute survey, and we'll share the data with you.
0 comments

GamesBeat is your source for gaming news and reviews. But it's also home to the best articles from gamers, developers, and other folks outside of the traditional press. Register or log in to join our community of writers. You can even make a few bucks publishing stories here! Learn more.

You are now an esteemed member of the GamesBeat community. That means you can comment on stories or post your own to GB Unfiltered (look for the "New Post" link by mousing over your name in the red bar up top). But first, why don't you fill out your via your ?

About GamesBeat