VentureBeat

Updated

When David Maestri launched Mob Wars in January of this year, he may have made a multi-million dollar mistake.

I have learned from a handful of sources that the entrepreneur, whose popular game is one of the most lucrative apps on Facebook, both developed and released Mob Wars while still employed at Freewebs, the company that later evolved into Social Gaming Network (SGN). By the time Maestri left the company around the middle of February, the game was already a hit.

Almost any tech company makes its employees sign agreements guaranteeing the company the rights to any intellectual property they produce while employed. Freewebs was no exception. And so, in a claim filed on August 11th in Maryland (where Freewebs, is legally registered) Freewebs and SGN have hit Maestri with a litany of charges, including breach of contract, breach of duty, misappropriation of trade secrets and interference with business relations. If the case goes to court and Maestri loses, he may have to surrender not only the rights to Mob Wars, but all the money he has made from its success, as well.

And with 2,505,698 monthly active users, a success it has been. In the game, a would-be mafioso starts off as a petty thief and must work his way to the top of the crime chain, earning points by fighting opposing gangsters, doing jobs, robbing stores and casinos and exploiting underlings. The player can improve his character by spending these points on better guns, real estate, loyalty and more, and while he could spend an eternity building up enough points to become a serious baller, he can also spend real cash to jumpstart the process.

It seems that Maestri has nailed the formula. Though we don’t know exactly how much cash he’s pulling in, one source told us that Maestri is the mystery app developer that makes a million dollars a month. Now he faces the possibility of losing it all. The tragic part — for Maestri, at least — is that if he’d just waited until he’d left Freewebs to begin development, his former employer would have a far harder time making the charges stick. As it stands, his position does not look very strong. Indeed, because Maestri stayed as long as he did, the company may be right to think that the key to his success with Mob Wars was his insight into the company’s infrastructure and intelligence.

As an aside, Maestri launched the game under the alias Jason Gilbert. He also once found himself in conflict with MySpace, which apparently offered him a job when it encountered RealEditor, a profile template creator he and a friend had built. When he turned the job down, MySpace went ahead and developed something quite similar, anyway.

I’ve reached out to both parties for comment and will update if I hear back.

[Update: Maestri has reached out to say that "Mob Wars is my creation and the legal process is moving forward." Also, the original story said that Maestri worked for SGN. Technically, he actually left Freewebs before SGN spun off into a separate entity, but this doesn't really change his situation.]

Eric Eldon contributed to the reporting on this story

[Image Credit: Electronic Arts]

Here’s the latest action:

1) Bizarre claim made by academic: France shipping nuclear waste to U.S.
2) Google up against new rivals, which can see what you surf
3) MingleNow is leaving the party
4) Solar’s scaling challenges may have an answer
5) Incandescent lighting heading for the door
6) Gaming feud could cause aftershocks
7) Freewebs relaunches as Webs.com
8) More money heads to Hollywood

U.S. denies France is shipping nuclear waste to South Carolina — At the ThinkGreen conference in San Francisco, University of Florida professor Yogi Goswami (pictured left), a former President of the International Solar Energy Society, made the bizarre claim that “a large majority of the nuclear waste from France is actually shipped to the U.S,” specifically to Savannah River Lab in South Carolina — and that not even the Department of Energy knows about it (story carried by Cleantech.com). Coming from an accomplished academic, at an investors conference, you’d think there is something to this (we talked with the Cleantech folks, and they say Goswami is respected). But the DOE denied Goswami’s claim, calling it inaccurate and misleading. Anyone know anything about this? We’ll do some digging, meantime.

Watch out, Google, the wolves are circling — The online ad business is hot, and there potential rivals to Google are numerous. Internet service providers like CenturyTel and Embarq Communications are starting to use their innate advantages to do ads, with targeting that really works: Since they serve their customers with internet service, they can track every Web site the customer visits. That’s far more than Google can do. The Wall Street Journal reports on their progress; for more on the actual technology, check out our own article on NebuAd, one of the technology companies behind so-called “deep packet inspection” techniques.

MingleNow decides to leave the party – A social network for the bar and club scene (our coverage) will close on January 7th, according to their blog, a little more than a year after launching. Perhaps nobody expected it to really succeed (see the comments on our original post), but Read/Write Web says an anonymous source tipped them off that the site was actually forced to close by Yahoo, which bought BlueLithium, owner of MingleNow.

Solar power may not find large-scale success — At least in its current form, says the American Scientist Online. The power required to manufacture photovoltaic equipment may make it difficult to scale installations quickly enough to satisfy global power demands. However, an upcoming technology called dye-sensitized cells may be cheap enough to solve an early production crunch. Check out the original article for more.

Incandescents speeding their exit from the market — As the above story implies, efficiency is a big part of the cleantech equation, which is why everyone from the Department of Energy to Wal-Mart is trying to eliminate incandescent lighting. It’s no news that initiatives to replace them with compact fluorescent bulbs and LEDS are going well, but an update on the progress is always nice; for the best one lately, check out this article on Chemical & Engineering News.

Gaming feud could have industry consequences — The peremptory and unexplained canning of an editor by popular gaming review site GameSpot may seem like a minor scuffle at first, but it could have broader implications for gaming as a whole, says GigaOm. The controversy the firing caused may push the industry further along the path to casual games with a broader market appeal and hurting the business of established gaming websites.

Freewebs launches social gaming, changes name to Webs — Freewebs, a social media company that hosts personal websites, is relaunching itself as Webs.com. The new site will include a social publishing site called Pagii, the old Freewebs site, and the Social Gaming Network, which offers games for play on the site or on social networks like Facebook. More coverage from Techcrunch.

More investment going to Hollywood — A new $200 million private equity fund raised by FilmBankers International LLC will invest directly in the production of independent films in the United States. The firm is still fundraising, but plans to use the money for films with a budget range of $10-20 million. FilmBankers bases funding decisions on a “credit score”, which attempts to predict the potential success of a film. The fund is part of a new wave of private capital headed for Hollywood, with hopes of outmaneuvering the time-worn blockbuster model of the big studios. News via TheDeal.com.