We're thrilled to announce the return of GamesBeat Next, hosted in San Francisco this October, where we will explore the theme of "Playing the Edge." Apply to speak here and learn more about sponsorship opportunities here. At the event, we will also announce 25 top game startups as the 2024 Game Changers. Apply or nominate today!
This review contains minor spoilers.
Let’s get this out of the way: I think you should play BioShock Infinite.
The first-person shooter from developer Irrational Games (due out March 26 for Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, and PC) is one of the biggest releases of this console generation. In production for five years, Infinite has to live up to its predecessor’s pedigree and justify that half-decade of hype.
GamesBeat Next 2023
Join the GamesBeat community in San Francisco this October 24-25. You’ll hear from the brightest minds within the gaming industry on latest developments and their take on the future of gaming.
Does it live up to those expectations? Not entirely, but I don’t know what could. What it does do is entertain and enthrall.
Players take the role of Booker DeWitt, the rogue who is in too deep with loan sharks. DeWitt takes a job to rescue a girl from Columbia, a floating American city, to wipe away his debts.
If you played the original BioShock, you’ll recognize much of the structure that holds up Infinite. This is definitely a “BioShock.” The adventure starts as abruptly as the last. Once you’re in Columbia, the world confronts you with extreme social issues. You’ll have access to special powers called Vigors that stand in for the Plasmids from the 2007 release. DeWitt finds audio recordings that flesh out the world. It even has a lighthouse.
Irrational settled on a specific style, and Infinite is a riff on that. And it’s a riveting take on the concept. It plays so well, and the urge to uncover Columbia’s mysteries are so compelling, that I ripped through its dozen hours of gameplay in two sittings.
When it was over, I was satisfied but also a little confused and a touch disappointed, and while that wouldn’t hurt most other games, this one is so meticulously crafted that you can’t ignore even the tiniest cracks.
What You’ll Like
Elizabeth is the aforementioned girl in need of rescuing. Well, “rescue” isn’t the right term. She really just needs a ride out of Columbia — otherwise, she can take care of herself.
You spend a good portion of Infinite accompanying this young, mysterious girl. Amazingly, not a single minute of that feels like an escort mission. Actually, it sometimes feels like she is escorting you.
Elizabeth never stands in a doorway, she’ll never harass you with banal banter, and she’ll never say something like “Can we get going?” If you want to stop and check every corner for cash and ammo, she’ll follow along and not just as some empty-headed A.I. assistant.
If you’re scavenging for items, she’ll go and lean against the wall — or occasionally, she’ll spot something and point it out to you. If you stop to look at a vending machine, she’ll take a seat at a nearby bench. If you pause to appreciate some art, she may walk up next to you and do the same. She’s a human with her own interests and motivations.
In combat, she serves two purposes. She finds extra ammo, items, and health and tosses it to DeWitt when he needs it most. She can also revive you when you lose all of your health.
Elizabeth also has trans-dimensional shifting powers that she can use to open existing portals to alternative realities. She can manifest powerful weapons, cover, or special platforms into your current reality using this ability. This gives the player another tool to use during combat.
I would consider Elizabeth a success if she simply never annoyed me, but her personality ensured that my relationship with her was about more than mere tolerance. All of Irrational’s tiny touches brought her to life, and I actually grew attached to her. Her routines are so systemically complex, the animation so precise, the voice acting so heartfelt that I will always remember BioShock Infinite as an adventure I shared with someone else.
Columbia is brilliantly realized
Irrational packed every square foot of Columbia with audio-visual information. The floating city is a dystopia of early 20th century Americana mixed with the white supremacy, anti-labor rhetoric and propaganda of the Jim Crow South and modern-day right-wing zealots.
In the way that the writings of Ayn Rand informed the world of BioShock, extremist conservatives like deceased Sen. Strom Thurmond of South Carolina or current conservative icon, Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky, inform BioShock Infinite’s mythology.
Columbia is a floating fortress that has taken the founding of the United States and twisted it into a religion. The city’s citizens literally pray to Benjamin Franklin, George Washington, and Thomas Jefferson. It’s an extreme take on the unquestioning reverence for America that echoes some of the rhetoric you might hear from the right-wing of the Tea Party.
On Columbia, the “coloreds” and the Irish must use special bathrooms. A manufacturing magnate named Jeremiah Fink runs a labor city that has employees bidding on minutes’ worth of work. He’ll occasionally come on the loudspeaker to talk about how the lowly workers should be happy to avoid all the responsibilities of the white man.
One billboard shows a good little boy pointing his rifle at a horrifying caricature of a Jewish child. Another shows a white family under the words “Columbia Security: Protecting our faith, wealth, and racial purity.”
This kind of propaganda exists throughout Infinite, and you can’t help but stop and examine each one. Irrational’s artists did an amazing job capturing the grotesqueness of this type of racial imagery, and it transported me to something that I have only seen in history books and documentaries.
I also found myself compelled to explore every corner of the city in the possibility that I might stumble across some fresh bit of propaganda. Smartly, Irrational awards players who wander off the intended path. Nearly every dead-end has some kind of item, voice recording, or upgrade waiting for you.
It’s basic but clever design.
Columbia also feels expansive. You can’t enter every store and home, but it never gets claustrophobic. You can take multiple paths, and if one street is blocked off, it’s because that part of town floated away. It’s an elegant solution to invisible walls.
The use of music sets the tone and adds to the narrative
Aurally, BioShock Infinite is a next-gen game.
Columbia is full of brilliant musical cues. Songs come across the radio. Barbershop quartets spontaneously appear on an airship and begin serenading you with an astounding cover song.
Nothing makes BioShock Infinite feel more like a bid-budget product than its use of music.
It’s not just that the songs sound good or pop up so naturally. It’s that they contribute to the storytelling. One of the first songs you hear is a metaphor Infinite. Another anachronistic tune helps flesh out the setting. The singing crowd helps guide you to where you need to go.
The combat is exciting and keeps the game moving at rapid pace
If the imagery and the music were constantly pushing me forward, the combat holds the varying sections together.
Shooting and using Vigors is a blast in two- to eight-minute chunks. One of the only battles that lasts longer than that gives you a unique and amazing ability near the end of the campaign.
The skyline mechanic, a roller-coaster like rail system that DeWitt can travel on by hanging from his special hook, also mixes up combat.
Personally, I had more fun exploring the world, but that’s not because the combat is lacking. Irrational uses fights to break up areas, and in that way it keeps the game’s pacing in check.
I had a difficult time putting down the controller because I was always one more fight or one more area away from the next discovery.
What You Won’t Like
The nonplayer characters
Irrational Games did a superb job crafting Infinite’s world. That’s why it’s so noticeable when certain things don’t work — like the citizens of Columbia.
The interactivity between DeWitt and the people of the city is so minimal that I thought the story would reveal they’re all really robots or under a spell. It’s very bizarre.
You’re exploring this incredibly detailed world, but every time you go to interact with a character that isn’t Elizabeth, everything falls apart.
Take the first few hours of Infinite: I spent my time stealing everything. Right in front of people. No one noticed or said anything. At a certain point, a pop-up notice will inform you that shop owners will now notice if you steal from them, but stealing is one the only interactions possible with many of the characters. At an ice cream parlor, I could steal something from the register or silently stare at the proprietor.
Speaking of silently staring, Infinite has a ton of that. For as expressive as Elizabeth is, the repeating character models for NPCs and their tendency to barely acknowledge your existence is distracting at the very least. It bothered me all the way up to the end, long after I had any interaction with a non-confrontational NPC.
What is worse is that for all of Infinite’s attempts to deal with racism and class warfare, I never got a sense of how that affected the characters.
Inifinite does an excellent job conveying the racism through the billboards or through the environment, but the actual population never felt like anything more than furniture. They make Columbia looked lived in but it doesn’t feel lived in.
I’d hesitate to even call the NPCs one-dimensional characters. It’s incredibly distracting and slightly lessens the impact the story and themes would otherwise have.
I’m going to talk about the ending in this section a little bit. I’ll try to avoid spoilers, but you may just want to skip to the conclusion.
Infinite’s ending is interesting. I don’t hate it, but I do have some questions. Questions the ending shouldn’t have left me with.
The first half of the resolution is actually a high-level twist on the whole BioSchock concept. I like that. It ties together some things about the BioShock universe in a very upfront and interesting way. It explains a lot of things that, as gamers, we are used to ignoring because we know that the developers didn’t ever consider them.
Irrational did consider them and provided a satisfying explanation.
The second half of the ending goes off the rails for me. It uses paradoxes and fails to explain how one of the characters turned out like he did. Either the ending is lacking some important information or I’m just too dumb to fill in the holes.
Either way, it didn’t work for me.
BioShock Infinite is a great game.
The combat is fun. The pacing is excellent. The world is fleshed out and filled with interesting things to discover. While portions of the story’s ending disappointed me, I don’t feel cheated because it was such an enjoyable ride.
Infinite’s biggest issue is that the stiff nonplayer characters really dampen the impact of the social themes. Irrational worked so hard building this world filled with terrible racial imagery, but it’s difficult to feel the effects of that when I can’t relate to the mechanical mannequins that populate Columbia.
It’s actually a minor complaint, but it’s very noticeable in a product that is otherwise so exquisitely put together.
It’s also beautiful set to high on my Nvidia GT 650M.
You should play BioShock Infinite. It shows what a top-tier developer can accomplish with a massive budget and a five-year production cycle. That way of doing things is on the way out, so it’s nice to get this reminder of just how impressive a big-budget game can be.
BioShock Infinite will come out for the PC, Xbox 360, and PlayStation 3 on March 26. 2K Games provided GamesBeat with a downloadable PC version of BioShock Infinite for the purpose of this review.
GamesBeat's creed when covering the game industry is "where passion meets business." What does this mean? We want to tell you how the news matters to you -- not just as a decision-maker at a game studio, but also as a fan of games. Whether you read our articles, listen to our podcasts, or watch our videos, GamesBeat will help you learn about the industry and enjoy engaging with it. Discover our Briefings.