Interested in learning what's next for the gaming industry? Join gaming executives to discuss emerging parts of the industry this October at GamesBeat Summit Next. Learn more.


Battleborn strides confidently into a fight I don’t think it will win.

Each market it’s trying to enter is crowded. Multiplayer online battle arenas (MOBAs) are littered with games trying to make it big as an esport, and you can play most of them for free. Games with long-term RPG hooks abound. Both Overwatch and Doom are set to capture the “competitive shooter” audience this year. And from the stories I’ve heard online and among friends, it seems like everyone’s settled on Battleborn falling by the wayside in the coming months.


Check out our Reviews Vault for past game reviews.


I hope that’s not the case. I had plenty of good moments during my 30 hours of Battleborn (out now on PlayStation 4, Xbox One, and PC, which is the version GamesBeat reviewed). But in a genre that demands a long-term commitment to pay off, I don’t think “good” is enough to push back against that tide of negativity.

Event

MetaBeat 2022

MetaBeat will bring together metaverse thought leaders to give guidance on how metaverse technology will transform the way all industries communicate and do business on October 3-4 in San Francisco, CA.

Register Here

Above: The Helix screen shows you your talent tree, as well as a quick rundown of your abilities.

What you’ll like

The key twists to the MOBA formula

If you know what a MOBA is, map several of those ideas on a first-person shooter and you’ll have a good idea of what Battleborn is. If you don’t, here are the basics: Rather than focusing on amassing kills or moving flags back and forth, you lead creeps (the hapless minions that mindlessly walk in a line) toward an objective, whether it’s an incinerator (in the Meltdown mode) or a giant robot (in Incursion). The enemy team wants to do the same, so you fight about it. You can play a more simplified point-capture mode, but it’s nowhere near as fun.

As you kill creeps, enemy players, and find gold in crystals around the map, you’ll level up, and unlock a new talents to layer on one of three skills (you start with two and unlock a third at level 5). Each character plays one of three roles (attacker, defender, or support), but the bonuses you pick can determine how much you specialize in a given role; supports usually stay back and make sure their allies don’t die, but they can turn into serious attackers, while defenders can provide their team with some support.

Implementing these ideas in a shooter might be interesting on its own, but the tweaks developer Gearbox Software makes to make sure they fit show some nuance. Incursion, the most MOBA-like mode, has only one lane of creeps, meaning players constantly funnel down the same area, leading to a constant stream of fights between players. Meltdown has two lanes, which forces you to spin more plates but also means you can help the team without being good at fighting if you can kill creeps while no one is looking.

If you find yourself falling behind in experience, you can always take a more passive approach by killing creeps and scouring the map for crystals until you’ve caught up. You can use gold to activate upgrades you pick out outside of matches and build turrets to help push enemy creeps back.

Meltdown is more prone to back and forths, while Incursion can force stalemates but makes the moments when you finally break through more rewarding. Both of these modes are smart deviations from the MOBA norm, and they show that Gearbox doesn’t just want to make a me-too product; they understand how this genre works and want to test their mettle.

Attacking crystals will give you the gold you need to activate the gear you've brought into battle.

Above: Attacking crystals will give you the gold you need to activate the gear you’ve brought into battle.

Image Credit: Suriel Vazquez/GamesBeat

When it all comes together

It took me a while to make sense of Battleborn. Even as someone who’s spent thousands of hours playing MOBAs and shooters, figuring out what I was supposed to do in a given match took several confusing loses. When should I go for a kill on an opponent, when should I let them go, and when should I focus on killing creeps and beating up crystals?

Building that intuition can take hours of playtime. But after a dozen or so hours I finally began having the intense matches the game wanted me to have: being down by over 150 points in Meltdown, then rallying a team together to slowly make a comeback, or the match where your team does so well in the first 5 minutes that the enemy team decides to call it quits right then and there.

And because I had to put in effort the learn the game, those victories felt sweeter than in most shooters. The rough losses are crushing, of course, but they come with the territory. I still haven’t crossed the hump where I fully understand all of Battleborn’s rhythms, but now that I have the hang of it, I’m having better matches, which makes my initial losses more worthwhile.

Battleborn's single-player lets you fight CPU opponents instead of humans.

Above: Battleborn’s single-player lets you fight bots instead of humans.

Image Credit: 2K

The single-player mode is meatier than you think

The trend among focused multiplayer games has been to go all-in on the competitive side rather than try to add a single-player campaign people will forget about months later. Games like Star Wars: Battlefront, Street Fighter V, and Rainbow Six: Siege all support the idea that multiplayer games can stand on their own.

I don’t begrudge this idea, but it’s encouraging to see a game like Battleborn have something for players to do besides kill each other. You can work your way through eight campaign missions alone, with friends, or in a group. These last about 30 minutes, but that’s just long enough to play a match, do a quick run through a mission, and then play another match having forgotten the trouncing you received an hour ago.

The single-player missions remind me of Borderlands without the connective role-playing game tissue (which shouldn’t be too surprising, considering Gearbox Software made both), and Battleborn has a surprising amount of dialogue between characters in each mission, and a few lines even made me laugh.

One of the things my friends tell me when they start playing competitive games of any genre is that they want a low-stakes environment to just learn a character. Having a single-player campaign gives new players something to work toward while learning different characters, which makes the transition into multiplayer a bit easier.

Above: To unlock characters, you can either play matches or rank up, or complete certain challenges.

What you won’t like

It’s a grind

Battleborn buries some of its best ideas under a sea of unlocks. You unlock characters either by ranking up or by completing specific challenges, like earning a certain number of wins from a particular faction or finishing every single-player mission on the hardest difficulty with a silver medal.

You unlock gear with points you earn at the end of every match. You can equip three different pieces of gear at once, and it makes you faster, stronger, and more resilient. Gear drops randomly, with several tiers (the stronger a piece of gear is, the more gold it costs to activate in a match). Worst of all, the same piece of gear can drop with different values (a gold piece of gear with the same name can give you either +6.78 percent or +6.87 percent attack speed, for example). This means that even if you get the piece of gear you were looking for, you might still be looking for it because the version you got wasn’t good enough.

You need to unlock “mutations” for every character by playing several matches as them. Remember when I explained how when you level up in a match, you can choose between two different talents for your abilities? Turns out you can pick a third option, but only after you’ve played enough of that character.

You also unlock titles, bits of flavor text, and costumes, but it’s the game-relevant unlocks I take issue with. They give you something to work toward, but keep you playing for extrinsic, and not intrinsic, reasons. That’s fine in a game like Diablo, but not in a competitive game. In order to have the “full” Battleborn experience, you’ll end playing characters you don’t like so you can unlock characters you might, play matches when you don’t feel like it to unlock more gear so you do well in later matches, and push yourself on the characters you do like playing so you can have access to their full potential. This might keep you playing, but not for the reason that matters: to have fun.

Author
Topics