Interested in learning what's next for the gaming industry? Join gaming executives to discuss emerging parts of the industry this October at GamesBeat Summit Next. Register today.


Check out our Review Vault for past reviews

To the uninitiated, pinball looks as random as a slot machine and has as much storytelling potential as the local church’s bingo-ball tumbler.

And I completely understand having that impression, but it’s also wrong. Pinball is a much more narrative genre than many realize. With Atlus’s Rollers of the Realm for PC (also out now on PlayStation 4 and PlayStation Vita), developer Phantom Compass wants to show the world the abstract narrative of pinball by splicing it with gaming’s go-to storytelling vehicle: the role-playing game.

Possessing the creativity and drive to attempt putting two different genres together is great. The thing is, even the most well-intentioned cross-breeding experiments don’t always go as planned.

Event

GamesBeat Summit Next 2022

Join gaming leaders live this October 25-26 in San Francisco to examine the next big opportunities within the gaming industry.

Register Here

What you’ll like

Rollers of the Realm dungeon

Above: So when building this prison for balls, maybe we shouldn’t have installed these giant flippers?

Image Credit: Phantom Compass

Silverball storytelling

The next time I have difficulty explaining how pinball can be a physically abstract storytelling experience, I’m just going to point at Rollers of the Realm.

Each ball represents a character with their own attributes and personalities. The main protagonist, a young thief, is small and crafty. When her ball smacks into the backside of a villager, she picks their pockets for gold coins.

The knight is the largest ball in Rollers of the Realm. His rolls are heavy in nature and lack finesse. But since this sphere is good for smashing through targets that smaller balls can’t, it balances out.

These physical attributes aren’t about cold, calculated mechanics. They reflect each character’s personality through play design.

The thief ball’s physical play reflects her quick wit and capability of handling herself in the city streets. Yet the hero’s journey that is thrust onto her is too large to handle alone. She needs companionship from the growing number of spheres that join the party (also in the form of a loyal dog themed ball that is tied to some of her special abilities).

The knight’s physical heaviness and lumbering nature is also an analogy for his depression, set on by a sense of disillusionment for the world around him. If only he knew he wasn’t really a knight, but a ball in a pinball game.

These ball-design metaphors may be heavy-handed, but the medium still seems to be in its infancy when it comes to expression-by-design. I applaud Phantom Compass on this attempt.

Rollers of the Realm castle gate

Above: They don’t like spheres wandering around their neighborhood.

Image Credit: Phantom Compass

Other little touches highlight pinball’s ability for narrative besides the personal life crisis of balls.

I especially like that the playfield represents a fantasy environment that happens to have pinball-like behavior, as opposed to bumpers and targets that have the cardboard facade of a village or castle.

For example, a well in the corner of a city square look like it would in any other game. It just so happens that a ball making contact with it evokes it to act like a pop bumper.

A shield carrying soldier standing in the middle of a road looks like he normally should. That is until you smack him with a sphere, making him act like a pinball target.

This is a small detail, but it really helps sell the narrative concept that this is a place, with people, and things are actually happening in this world. If they had taken the visuals to the other direction, of pinball contraptions wearing the thin mask of fantasy items, the immersion of the narrative in a pinball world wouldn’t have been as smooth.

Creative ball ideas

Rollers of the Realm the healer

Above: The patron saint of rolling around.

Image Credit: Phantom Compass

From the mechanical standpoint of pinball, Phantom Compass is trying some cool ideas. Each ball has its own set of stats and equipment upgrades, which manipulate behavior. Such as how much damage it deals to a target, how quickly it rolls across the playfield, and how easily it can be controlled.

Each character also has a special set of powers, which you can activate separately from the flipper controls. These special powers offer some fun stuff like pumped up melee attacks, firing projectiles at enemies, and creating protection from drain holes.

Making every ball unique teases the possibility of strategic character combos for specific playfield situations. Phantom Compass is taking full advantage of video pinball’s ability to do things that are impossible for real-life machines to perform.

Control your balls

Rollers of the Realm roof top attack

Above: Again. We built this tower in case of a ball attack. Who decided the giant flippers would be a good addition?

Image Credit: Phantom Compass

Phantom Compass also does a great job at making sure the majority of the real-world pinball skills made the transition to Rollers of the Realm. Post passing, which involves flipping a held ball off of a post in order to pass it to the opposite flipper, works in environments where slingshot-like items are available.

Drop catches also work. This is a technique where you drop a flipper just as the ball is going to make contact, killing its momentum so it can be cradled.

I won’t name off every ball control technique, but experienced pinball players will be able to do most of the staple moves.

I did say, “most.” Maneuvers that are rubber intensive in real-life pinball don’t work so well in Rollers of the Realm. The most obvious is the dead flipper pass. This skill requires not activating the flippers at all when the ball is screaming down towards them. This will make the ball bounce off of the flipper as if it were a rubber wall, killing some of the momentum and bouncing it over to the other flipper to be cradled. It’s a very common, basic control skill.

Rollers of the Realm forrest

Above: The flippers grow wild here.

Image Credit: Phantom Compass

Since there is very little to no rubber-like physics in Rollers of the Realm, the ball will thud into the flipper and not bounce over. It’s not a negative, but it definitely affects how I would otherwise play out certain situations.

Nudging is also handled in a different manner. Instead of shoving the entire environment around, you can alter the trajectory of the ball directly. It has some interesting things you can do with this, such as control how a ball handles a bounce or adding an artificial curve to its trajectory. The latter comes in handy when you want to sneak around an enemy soldier and stab them in the back.

Obviously, some of this is going to irk hardcore players, but none of this bothers me. These controls provide enough real-life technique that it does not divorce the pinball concept, and it gives Rollers of the Realm a unique play identity.

What you won’t like

Rollers of the Realm battle

Above: You see, man, every time a ball walks into the bar, the whole place goes to hell.

Image Credit: Phantom Compass

Cool ideas are off-balance

The mana meter system in Rollers of the Realm needs some serious tweaking.

Traditional pinball scoring disappears here, replaced by two valuable pieces of currency: mana and gold. Mana resides in a bar on the U.I., with no additional levels. Once it’s full, you must spend it in order to take advantage of any additional mana you’re earning on the playfield.

That’s fine. But it has a big problem: I can spend the entire mana bar on reviving a dead ball.

These character balls may have some cool special abilities, but none of them trump generating an extra life. Situations where it was considered smart to spend mana on anything not geared toward revival were extremely rare.

Another big balancing issue that this plays into is in the character roster. Special moves, if I decide to spend the mana on them, are all over the board as far as their usefulness. If they are tied to multiball (which I will get to in a bit), forget it. Don’t even bother. While characters that fire off projectiles seemed to be automatic top-tier candidates for a lot of situations.

Rollers of the Realm knight

Above: If I get rolled over by a giant ball today on guard duty, tell my wife and kids that I love them.

Image Credit: Phantom Compass

It gets worse, unfortunately, because even if we put aside the poorly balanced special abilities, the entire roster would boil down to two balls just based off of their play style: the hunter and the healer.

The hunter, when maxed out, absolutely pin-cushions any enemy it happens to roll near. When so much of the playfield design is about killing things, it is always in my best interest to both keep this ball in play and to hold on to mana to revive it.

The other highly valuable ball, the healer, is brought in when the flippers have taken too much damage. As long as I flip her toward a mana-generating object, I’ll regain healthy flippers in no time. Then I simply swap to the hunter again.

Maybe a case can be made that I’m, “Playing the game wrong.”

I doubt it.

The other balls need abilities that are as useful as the projectile and heal characters, with a mana system that isn’t relegated to revival only. Maybe tie revival to spending a large amount of gold or having to buy a special, expensive, item in the shop? That would at least free the system up so players will be tempted to use more of the special moves.

Multiball is worthless

Rollers of the Realm multiball

Above: Not McCloud! He was just two days from retirement!

Image Credit: Phantom Compass

The most useless of the character specific special moves in Rollers of the Realm are tied to pinball’s most beloved mode: multiball.

Multiball in traditional pinball is a time-honored risk-and-reward mechanic. A player’s ball control skills are taxed to their limit when they have to manage multiple spheres at one time. The misconception is that having a second or third ball in play is safer than one.

It absolutely is not. You are in constant danger of draining everything at once with multiple balls flying around.

The true payoff for all this ball juggling is in the huge scores that come with it. The rewards are typically associated with something like a huge jackpot shot being available or the scoring on the playfield being multiplied.

None of this is taken into consideration in Rollers of the Realm. Activating a character’s multiball ability makes the game more difficult with no benefits. The only bonus is that collecting mana, swiping gold, and damaging enemies can be done slightly quicker (since more balls are running into them at once). And you can earn all of this, anyway, if you play patiently with one ball.

Why risk losing a valuable character ball micromanaging additional worthless balls with nothing to gain?

Nothing to come back for

Rollers of the Realm tomb

Above: Tomb of the unknown tilter.

Image Credit: Phantom Compass

The levels throughout the campaign are meticulously designed as small pinball chapter markers that lead us down a linear narrative. That’s also the root of Rollers of the Realm’s troubles.

Like every RPG, Rollers of the Realm encourages backtracking through these environments to grind away for experience points and gold. Without the narrative facade given in the original play through, these playfields wind up being embarrassingly shallow their second time around. The objectives are watered down to soldier-bashing and hitting a specific item a certain amount of times.

Great pinball design, both video and real life, is able to entice me back with so much more than what is provided here while not being overly complicated. I may have to bash an object over and over again in some real-life games, but it is always tied to something a bit more intriguing.

Grinding may be a trope of the RPG, but no one should put up with play becoming a boring chore. Good pinball, especially, should never feel tedious. It needs to be like a good puzzle game, one I may shelf for a while after the first few playthroughs but never actually quit — let alone dread.

Conclusion

Phantom Compass seems so tied up in getting the single player RPG elements to plug in, that in the shuffle it has missed what’s needed to make a compelling pinball experience.

Experimentation in a medium full of clones is laudable. If I could criticize based off of concepts alone, Phantom Compass’s bold idea would earn Rollers of the Realm a damned near perfect score. Unfortunately, in the real world you have to see those ideas through. And usually the bitch that tears good intentions apart is in the transition from drawing board to the real deal.

In Rollers of the Realm’s case, it’s most compelling as a one-and-done. If you have a difficult time grasping the concept of abstract narrative in pinball, it will be a fantastic eye-opener. Taken any further than that, expecting the replay of almost every other pinball option out there, and it disappoints.

60/100

Rollers of the Realm is available now on PlayStation 4, PC (Steam), and PlayStation Vita. The publisher provided GamesBeat with a Steam code. 

GamesBeat's creed when covering the game industry is "where passion meets business." What does this mean? We want to tell you how the news matters to you -- not just as a decision-maker at a game studio, but also as a fan of games. Whether you read our articles, listen to our podcasts, or watch our videos, GamesBeat will help you learn about the industry and enjoy engaging with it. Discover our Briefings.