Unfortunately, Supreme League of Patriots moves so slowly that it makes a good premise and a decent story completely stultifying.
It has too much dialogue, most of it throwaway, that you must sit through if you want to proceed. In several cases, you must go in a different location and talk with another character who can’t help you, just to prompt the dialogue options you need from the one who obviously can.
Supreme League makes a ton of self-referential jokes about adventure games early on, then proceeds to use nearly every one of the hackneyed tropes it mocks.
It teases you for examining everything, and then it forces you to examine everything. It laughs about arbitrary puzzles, and then it forces you to put together four items in a scene not an hour later that must be done in one particular order, or they won’t work (even though in real life you could have used any order you liked).
GamesBeat Summit 2023
Join the GamesBeat community in Los Angeles this May 22-23. You’ll hear from the brightest minds within the gaming industry to share their updates on the latest developments.
Frustratingly, you must frequently talk with people, running through all their dialogue options, to get permission to solve the puzzles you already know the answers to … incredibly obvious puzzles.
The result is a superhero game that crawls when it should fly, and you end up spam-clicking through dialogue and jokes and fairly good voice acting because, please, you’ve been in this room forever, and you just want to fix the thing you knew how to fix the moment you walked in oh my god.
The clunky animation style and Kyle’s character development
This is the first game from No Bull, and while some players might like the distinctly throwback animation style, I’m not a fan. The characters look like something chunky and poorly animated from the late ’80s/early ’90s, and not in a fun retro way. Their movements are stilted and strictly scripted. The lip sync is crude.
The character design itself is generally fine — a recurring gay character is a flaming stereotype, but everyone else gets to be more or less a human being — but most end up staring emotionlessly off into space for the duration of their time onscreen.
One conceit of the game is that Kyle becomes obnoxiously discriminatory after thinking he’s the Purple Patriot. He insults women, gay people, immigrants, and pretty much any other group he can think of. The joke is that by becoming a “patriot” in real life in his Uncle Sam suit and goatee, this is now how he thinks.
The game laughs at him making the jokes — now he’s gone and turned Republican, other characters say, making that a stereotypical attack as well — but the complaints aren’t funny. They’re just a tired rehash of stereotypes, delivered without a twist. It’s ugly, and it gets old extremely quickly. This isn’t politically incorrect humor, which could be hilarious when done well. It’s just stupid, which isn’t funny.
Please, please stop the music
At first I was charmed by the ’70s funky groove of the original musical soundtrack, which seemed like a good match with the game’s lighthearted subject matter.
Individual characters get musical themes when you approach them, which is an interesting (if frequently stereotypical) touch. A Hispanic female receptionist gets a Spanish flamenco riff, for example; a stern Rocky-villain-like character gets a Russian march.
But the music is loud enough and the dialogue quiet enough that if you’re listening, it’s right in your ear the whole time. After a while, I realized that it bore strong similarities to especially aggressive elevator music.
By the time I finished the second chapter, I was certain that this was the particular soundtrack of the elevator that leads to the depths of hell, the one that will never let you off, punishing you forever by bow-chica-bowbowing until you lose your increasingly fragile grip on your sanity.
I wanted to like Supreme League of Patriots in the worst way because of its point-and-click adventure genre, its voice acting, its promise of humor, and its intriguing story. But by the third episode, I couldn’t be rid of it fast enough.
Painfully slow to play, out of tune and obnoxious when it came to handling Kyle’s character(s), and grating to listen to when people weren’t talking, it took what could have been a delightful story and stretched it on a rack, set it on fire, and forced me to randomly talk with four people before grabbing the bucket of water I could clearly see on the counter to try to help put it out.
In the end, I was ready to just stand back and watch it burn.
Supreme League of Patriots is available now for PC, Mac, and Linux in three episodes of $6 each or a season pass of $15. It was developed by No Bull Intentions and published by Phoenix Online Studios, which provided GamesBeat with download codes for this review.
GamesBeat's creed when covering the game industry is "where passion meets business." What does this mean? We want to tell you how the news matters to you -- not just as a decision-maker at a game studio, but also as a fan of games. Whether you read our articles, listen to our podcasts, or watch our videos, GamesBeat will help you learn about the industry and enjoy engaging with it. Discover our Briefings.