Update with a response from FriendFeed’s Paul Buchheit, below the article

Facebook has just launched a new feature that lets you add actions from other sites to the mini-feed of actions on your profile, including sites like local review site Yelp, photo site Picasa, and others.

This capability, of course, is vaguely similar to what FriendFeed offers. FriendFeed lets you import actions from other sites onto its own, then track what your friends are up to around the web and discuss everything all in one place.

The problem is, Facebook is about a lot of things that distract users away from tracking what their friends are up to around the web. Distractions include: Posting messages on your friends’ walls, sending them private messages, “poking” them, playing applications with people, checking out friends’ photo albums, etc.

Facebook doesn’t have an effective way to let people easily converse about what they’re up to around the web, so I don’t think this new feature is going to mean serious competition with Friendfeed, at least for Friendfeed’s core user base. More on that in a minute.

This Facebook move reminds me of when Facebook decided to offer a somewhat similar feature to messaging service Twitter last year, which it called “status updates.” Twitter lets you post short messages about what you’re up to, reply to others’ messages, share links, etc. It’s a sort of abbreviated, instantaneous — yet asynchronous — conversation with other Twitter users. Facebook’s updates feature, on the other hand, doesn’t offer the same dynamic. Instead, it’s more just a way for you to say what you’re up to, that others might see as they look at their news feed (which, incidentally, seems to be broken today), or as they look at your Facebook profile.

Twitter has been growing by leaps and bounds, and seems to be more popular than much-larger Facebook within the tech world. However, lots of people use both, even using Twitter’s Facebook application to post tweets (Twitter messages), and importing tweets into their Facebook statuses.

Here’s how this second point connects back to Friendfeed. I’ve noticed that most of my Facebook friends under the age of 26 or so don’t use Twitter — unless they’re in the tech world. But they do use Facebook’s status updates pretty religiously.

Twitter has a large niche carved out for itself, a fairly differentiated service, and solid growth. But Facebook may be pre-empting Twitter’s ability to reach college kids and other heavy Facebook users.

In the same way, Friendfeed has been growing fast in the tech world — from what I can tell — and is a valuable place for keeping track of friends. It may be that Facebook users will be satisfied enough with Facebook’s overlapping feature being released today, that they won’t feel the need to also use Friendfeed. It doesn’t mean Friendfeed is doomed, it just might reduce its potential to grow big.

Update: Friendfeed’s Paul Buchheit responds

We’ve known about this feature for a while — they pre-announced it a couple of months ago. It’s also possible to import content from these sites using third-party apps, such as http://apps.facebook.com/mypicasawebalbums/

I view aggregation more as a feature or mechanism than a product. I expect that other services will continue to add the ability to import feeds — the entire web is moving the direction of linked and interconnected services, and that is a good thing.

FriendFeed is creating an interesting and enjoyable place to share and discuss things with friends — the aggregation aspect is more of an implementation detail. As you mentioned in your article, the actual experience of using FriendFeed is very different from Facebook, and I think they have very different strengths and purposes and for the most part are headed in different directions.

Tags: ,
Trackback URL

7 Trackbacks

  1. Facebook Becomes an Aggregator, Too « The Real McCrea said:

    [...] Mark Hendkrickson says, a threat to FriendFeed? Sort of. Is it a threat to Twitter, as Venture Beat’s Eric Eldon writes? I don’t think [...]

  2. Com’è andata a finire? #1: Facebook vs FriendFeed « GeekMarketing said:

    [...] Aggiornamento del 15 aprile 2008: Facebook is kinda competing with FriendFeed, like it kinda competes with Twitter [...]

  3. Facebook’s Lifestream: Nothing to See Here | 网络赚钱网摘 said:

    [...] the focus of the social-media-addicted tech community - something that MG does quite well on his VentureBeat post, "Facebook is kinda competing with FriendFeed, like it kinda competes with [...]

  4. Battle Of The Commodity Web Applications: It’s All About People - Publishing 2.0 said:

    [...] are Twitter and FriendFeed features, or are they companies? Eric Eldon makes a strong case that many of Facebook’s younger core users will never user Twitter or FriendFeed because the [...]

  5. How Twitter is like soap, or Soylent Green - mathewingram.com/work said:

    [...] just the Facebook status update as a standalone app. Theoretically, Facebook should be able to duplicate most of its features, or FriendFeed’s for that matter. But at the end of the day, it isn’t the features that [...]

  6. Telephony 2.0 » Blog Archive » Reading List: What’s Wrong with Google?; iPhone + VoiP; P2P’s Nonsensical Bill of Rights said:

    [...] There’s an interesting debate going on in the Web world as Facebook sucks in features from high-novelty competitors like FriendFeed and Twitter: will popular new Web services exist as standalone businesses (ie, maintain growth, find revenue) [...]

  7. April 21st, 2008
    12:39 pm

    Google wants to turn your home page into your social network » VentureBeat said:

    [...] that made the activity stream popular (it calls it the “News Feed”). It recently unveiled an update that allows users to import other data into that feed as well. This is an attempt to make Facebook [...]

3 Comments

  1. keith said:

    “Twitter has been growing by leaps and bounds, and so has a far-larger following than Facebook”

    um…what?

  2. Eric Eldon said:

    um, yeah, keith, that was an editorial typo and i’ve clarified

  3. John McCrea said:

    Eric, nice post. Sorry my fast-trigger post was based in part on a miss-reading of yours! I’ve updated mine now to correct that. Sorry!

    http://therealmccrea.com/2008/04/15/facebook-becomes-an-aggregator-too/

    Either way, I think this is an interesting sign of much bigger changes to come — for Facebook and the Social Web ecosystem as a whole.

Add a Comment