While everyone throws a fit over Apple and AT&T’s tricky pricing for the iPhone 3G, the real travesty in pricing is slipping by largely unnoticed: AT&T is including no text messages in its iPhone 3G monthly plans.
This means that on top of your cellular plan, and on top of your new 3G data plan, you will need to purchase a text messaging plan. This is a rip-off of epic proportions.
Lets think about this for a minute. What is a text message? It’s a relatively tiny amount of data (160 characters or fewer) that is sent using the short messaging service (SMS). With the iPhone’s unlimited data plan, which includes everything but texting, you’re probably sending hundreds of megabytes, and soon gigabytes, of data each month for $20-$30. Yet to send 200 of these 160-character text messages, it will likely be $5 to $10 extra a month.
A text message is data, and a very small amount of it. So why am I paying so much extra — let alone anything extra for it?
This seems like it would be a perfect candidate for one of those “Fleecing of America” segments that run on the NBC Nightly News — except that it’s arguably worse in the rest the world. Of the 2.3 trillion text messages are expected to be sent this year, the United States represents a relatively small percentage with “only” 300 billion sent. Not surprisingly, China is the largest market for the messages, with well over 500 billion sent. Mobile companies are making billions of dollars off of these messages.
Even worse is that carriers effectively double charge for each message. They charge both the sender and recipient of each one. In the United States these messages usually cost around 10 cents per message but can go as high as 25 cents a message without a pre-paid plan.
If you’re anything like me, you’re going to use many more than just 200 messages included in a bare-bones plan. Like many first generation iPhone owners, I signed up with the default 200 messages that were included in the original plans. One month I overshot this by 350 messages, and I would hardly consider myself a heavy text messenger.
But the iPhone seems to do that. Just as it has spurred use of the Internet on mobile phones, the iPhone has made text messaging very appealing to me. One reason is that I actually have a keyboard now instead of using that bogus T9 typing mechanism all of my previous phones had. And the other is that Apple makes text messaging look just like its iChat application, with conversations threaded just like an IM.
I use text messaging on the iPhone now just like I use IM. This is a major problem when I only have 200 messages I can send or receive — and each one after that is 10 cents a message. I upgraded my plan to 1500 messages, but under this new iPhone 3G payment structure, this is likely to add around $20 to my monthly bill. Everyone is all up in arms over the $10 raise for 3G data plan, what about the extra $20 many of us are going to have to pay?
Perhaps one of the companies building applications will come up with a way to circumvent this ridiculous charge for text messages. During Apple’s SDK road map event, AOL was unveiled as partner to bring its AOL Instant Messenger program to the iPhone, but we didn’t hear anything about it at WWDC. Hopefully that is still in the cards, because it could be exactly what I’m looking for — assuming that Apple’s new Push Notification Service works as well as advertised.
Instant messaging on phones with unlimited data plans such as the iPhone could easily kill text messaging. And it should, because I don’t want to keep paying for unlimited data only to have it be limited to certain kinds of data.
Text messaging almost makes the mobile industry’s other scam, the ringtone, look like a deal. And it makes that $10 a month extra on your iPhone bill for 3G data look like a steal.
[Check out MobileBeat2008, VentureBeat's mobile conference on July 24. Vote for your favorite mobile application or service company]
[photo: flickr/brymo]
1:04 am
The real iPhone 3G rip-off: Text messages | Txtin said:
[...] Original post by sms - Google News [...]
2:05 am
c 3 5 data structure said:
[...] AT&T is including no text messages in its iPhone 3G monthly plans. This means that on top of youhttp://venturebeat.com/2008/06/12/the-real-iphone-3g-rip-off-text-messages/Learn about The Top 10 Dairy Companies Marketwire via Yahoo! Finance Reportlinker.com announces that [...]
6:44 am
Apple Iphone 3g Rip Off | Live Crunch said:
[...] The real iPhone 3G rip-off: Text messages [via Zemanta] [...]
3:41 pm
The iPhone 3G (at least pretends) to be cheaper to buy because it’s cheaper to make » VentureBeat said:
[...] still contend that the true rip-off is the text-messaging plan for the [...]
1:36 am
first payment default said:
[...] AT&T is including no text messages in its iPhone 3G monthly plans. This means that on top of youhttp://venturebeat.com/2008/06/12/the-real-iphone-3g-rip-off-text-messages/Is this the end of down-payment “gift” programs? Seattle TimesThe Federal Housing Administration [...]
5:11 pm
Rumor: iPhone 3G to include MMS after all » VentureBeat said:
[...] 200 free text-messages will no longer included with basic plans. We’ve written that this is the true rip-off of the new iPhone (as opposed to paying more for the 3G data) on AT&T’s behalf because it will likely add [...]
10:36 pm
trillion messenger said:
[...] AT&T is including no text messages in its iPhone 3G monthly plans. This means that on top of youhttp://venturebeat.com/2008/06/12/the-real-iphone-3g-rip-off-text-messages/Danny Schechter: Wall Street’s Woes Are Our Call to Action HuffingtonPostThe media reform conference [...]
11:03 am
iPhone 3G: You can buy one without a contract, but not on launch day » VentureBeat said:
[...] of these plans will include text-messages — as I’ve stated before, this is the real rip-off. Despite having an “unlimited” data plan, it will cost you an extra $20 for unlimited [...]
7:41 pm
AT&T Announces iPhone 3G Pricing » Webomatica - Technology and Entertainment Digest said:
[...] The fact that text messages are now unbundled from the data is slightly annoying (MG Sielger agrees). [...]
6:02 pm
Google Talk comes to the iPhone, death of the text message approaching? » VentureBeat said:
[...] is in its promise. A real instant messaging service could greatly eliminate the need for the massive rip-off that is text messaging. It’s not there yet, for this app to currently work, you have to have your Safari browser [...]
1:23 am
Startup Meme » Blog Archive » Google Talk,Agile Messenger come to iPhone – Goodbye expensive sms? said:
[...] text messaging plans have been included by AT&T in its iPhone 3G monthly plans, which is a massive rip off for customers as text messages don’t really cost the carriers that much. Despite giving a pretty [...]
5:24 am
Chatter on Taxing the Text | Viraload said:
[...] that will increase over data plan by another $20-30. Venture Beat considers the new data plan a 3G rip-off [...]
12:14 pm
Apple blames Canada’s Rogers Wireless for ripping-off customers, pulls iPhone 3Gs » VentureBeat said:
[...] by Rogers’ plans, feel free to sign the Ruinediphone petition and look at the bright side, at least your plans include some free text messages, right? Tags: co:Apple, co:rogers SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: “Apple blames Canada’s [...]
12:22 am
Tapulous wants to be leading application ecosystem for the iPhone » VentureBeat said:
[...] Garnett, and Jeff Clavier. He said one investor originally expressed skepticism, saying that SMS is where all the money on mobile phones is being made. However, Decrem won him over, arguing that exclusive focus on the iPhone’s interface will [...]
1:54 pm
New Facebook iPhone app tells Twitter and SMS what it’s doing: Gunning for them » VentureBeat said:
[...] MG Siegler has extensively covered the slow death of SMS fees; considering that Facebook is popular with lots of young people [...]
9:21 pm
sumanpark's me2DAY said:
만박의 생각…
무제한 데이터 요금제가 기본인 휴대폰과 여기에 인터넷 기반의 Push Notification Service는 보편적 한국인들의 문자메시지 이용패턴을 어떻게 바꿀 것인가. 2010년대 이후에는 완전히 대세가 뒤바…
2:25 am
Roundup: Microsoft/Icahn offered Yahoo $2.3B, the Gphone continues to be imaginary and more » VentureBeat said:
[...] rates? Bypass them. — I’ve gone on rants a few times now about just how big of a rip-off text messages are. Now, thanks to the new AOL Instant Messenger (AIM) app on the iPhone you can bypass them. TidBITS [...]
12:08 am
iPhail: The Marketing Failure Behind the 3G iPhone | Marketing Ninja said:
[...] your phone + service will cost me over the same period of time, you’re doing it wrong. The data plan doesn’t cover text messages, the syncing features cost extra, existing iPhone customers can’t figure out if they’re [...]
7:21 pm
Twitter has its search, now it’s time to embrace mobile » VentureBeat said:
[...] Just imagine how useful a location-aware Twitter app could be (to those who choose to use such functionality). Imagine a Twitter app with Summize search built into it. Twitter could be the de-facto application of this new mobile generation. It could kill the colossal rip-off that is the text message. [...]
3:04 am
SMS Text News » Archives » SMS - die already (Short Message Scam) said:
[...] I would pay $10 more a month and then got used to the number. And then, MG Siegler at VentureBeat blew the lid off the iPhone hype (at least in my mind) by reading the small print. The 200 text messages that used [...]
8:14 pm
Twitter kills SMS service in some countries over costs. Will someone kill SMS already? » VentureBeat said:
[...] yet carriers seem to think it’s okay to charge an arm and a leg for it. In the United States, AT&T switched its policy with the iPhone 3G and no longer included any text messages in its plan…. Now, if you want to send message it’s $5 for 200 of them. That is ridiculous when you [...]
11:08 am
Twitter shuts down SMS in all but 3 countries. What next?! | Startup Meme said:
[...] yet carriers seem to think it’s okay to charge an arm and a leg for it. In the United States, AT&T switched its policy with the iPhone 3G to no longer include any text messages in its plans …. Now, if you want to send messages it’s $5 for 200 of them. That is ridiculous when you already [...]
4:59 am
iPhail: The Marketing Failure Behind the 3G iPhone said:
[...] much your phone + service will cost me over the same period of time, you’re doing it wrong. The data plan doesn’t cover text messages, the syncing features cost extra, existing iPhone customers can’t figure out if they’re going [...]
4:40 pm
Want to bypass iPhone SMS fees for Twitter updates? Get JustUpdate » VentureBeat said:
[...] (text message) rates in general are ridiculous, but they’re arguably worse for Apple’s iPhone 3G. Whereas the original iPhone included 200 free text messages with your data plan, the 3G data plan [...]