Water scarcity woes point to big opportunities in desalination

The drying of the western U.S. and recent news that California is in its second year of a drought has notched up the urgency of water issues. One potential solution is desalination, but such systems have long been considered pricey energy hogs. That’s fine for oil rich countries near the sea like those in the Middle East, but elsewhere it has been a major impediment.

Luckily for desalination technology manufacturers, there’s actually a triple threat to the water supply poised to drive business their way: Climate change, water scarcity and decaying infrastructure.

The economics of desalination are changing, but remain difficult for most municipalities. One plant under construction in Carlsbad, California expects to pay $1.10 in electricity to produce 1,000 gallons of water, down from $2.10 at the mothballed Santa Barbara plant. According to Meng Lean, manager of microfluidic systems at the Palo Alto Research Center (PARC), the energy cost of desalination runs at about eight times that of conventional water, with the most efficient plants requiring 15 watts per gallon, per hour.

A little known fact, however, is that desalination technology costs have fallen by as much as 80 percent over the past few years, by some estimates. Couple that stat with the total global desalination capacity growth of more than 47 percent over the past five years, according to a recent Credit Suisse investment report, and all of a sudden, desal looks a bit more attractive.

One company benefiting from the good news is Energy Recovery, a little known startup in San Leandro, Calif., considering an IPO. The company has to date taken only $9.5 million from private investors.

Energy Recovery has a pre-water treatment technology for desalination systems that has significant advantages over current technology. The company’s unique PX Pressure Exchanger uses the principle of positive displacement and isobaric chambers. The configuration can achieve a highly efficient energy transfer from a high-pressure brine waste stream in a reverse osmosis desalination unit, to a low-pressure incoming feed stream.

Energy Recovery claims its PX system is 98 percent efficient, which means that very little energy is lost in the transfer. “It changes the economics by quite a lot,” says a company official. That’s because the energy in a seawater desalination plant accounts for roughly 50 to 75 percent of systems return on investment.

Another promising technology in the world of desalination systems is innovative membrane technology. “Nano-engineered membranes are probably one of the most promising technologies out there,” says PARC’s Lean. These ultra thin nano-membranes from startups like NanoH20 in Los Angeles and Aqua Via in Hayward, Calif. are still in their early days of testing and will take several years before they’re ready to scale up to large deployments.

Lean says PARC researchers have also been working on membrane-less filtration systems that have a very low energy cost of roughly .11 watts per gallon per hour. This system, called the spiral concentrator, could eventually be used in pre-treatment for desalination systems, he adds.

As with gasoline, there’s the potential that water costs in the United States, which average $2.50 per thousand gallons, will rise to something closer to the standard European price of three to five times more. Between shortages and rising prices, it looks like a big opening is appearing for new desal technologies.

Next Story: Twitter brings in big guns from Pivotal Labs to help rebuild its troubled infrastructure
Previous Story: Surf Canyon adds Craigslist support to help you find your next apartment

Bookmark and Share

Tags: , ,

Photo of Lee Bruno

About the Author, Lee Bruno

  • Peter Antypas
    In many ways, I feel, the solutions in this space will mirror those for renewable energy: We'll see more decentralized production to replace aging and obsolete distribution networks.
  • The tough part of this is selling to municipalities - talk about a long sales cycle coupled with major budget restraints.
  • Eric
    Two questions for the author or anyone else:

    1. What is the source of the graph (labeled "Figure 20" but the text is too blurry to read the source) in this article?

    2. What is the title of the Credit Suisse report mentioned in the article? Can you provide a link or download?

    Thanks.
  • Lee Bruno
    In answer to your questions, here you go. The title of the report is Water, June 2007. Can't find a URL where you can download the report. I suggest contacting Credit Suisse. Here is the press release - www.credit-suisse.com/news/en/media_release.jsp.... The chart is from page 21 on the report and the title of the graph is growth in desalination. The source for the data is www.ewatermark.org. Hope this helps.
  • Eric
    Thanks, Lee.