“At first we were worried about MySpace, but then we realized that people use it differently from our site,” an employee at social network Facebook told me over a year ago. What he meant is that Facebook is a place for people to put their real lives online, providing factual information about themselves and having trusted interactions with their friends. Meanwhile, rival MySpace is more of a place for people to live out their fantasy lives online, borrowing celebrity photos for their profile pictures, adding far-fetched biographical information and such — MySpace uses the term “self-expression” to describe this behavior.

These cultural differences are, of course, not true across the board but are generally obvious to anyone who uses both social networks. And they’re a huge deal, even though most coverage I’ve seen doesn’t acknowledge it.

Facebook’s global user numbers have boomed from around 40 million monthly unique visitors in April, 2007 to 115 million unique monthly users this past April, with 62 million new users coming from outside the US.

Compare that to MySpace, which counts 73 million of its global users in the US and is now globally a close second to Facebook, having hardly grown anywhere over the past year. In fact, another traffic measurement firm, Nielsen Online, says that MySpace had 4.7 million U.S. visitors in April, down 30 percent from last year. [Note: This is a bizarrely low number, although the BBC and WebProNews are citing it -- I'm looking for confirmation from Nielsen. I'm sticking with comScore numbers for now.]

Taking a deeper dive into Facebook’s growth in regions around the world, it’s important to note that in many places MySpace has never been dominant. For example, another social network, hi5 — which has an interface more similar to MySpace’s, has been the market leader in Spanish-speaking Latin American countries for years. And while hi5 is still growing fast, Facebook has been busy catching up to it in a matter of months, especially after Facebook released a Spanish-language version of its site in March.



How Facebook is keeping it real


Facebook’s growth is global in more ways than one. While it continues to have a relatively white collar, college-based user population in the U.S., it has seen uptake across all demographics in other countries. For example, when the site took off in Canada in the winter of 2007, two-thirds of the entire city of Toronto quickly joined, not just the rich kids. Facebook employees tell me they’ve seen the same pattern in every country outside of the U.S.

Facebook started as a college campus hit in the U.S., with students using the service to share information like which dorm they lived in, what movies they liked, and who they hooked up with. If they provided fake information, their friends from across the hall would simply leave comments saying so on their profile pages. Facebook built this real-world community aspect into its site through local and regional networks that you join when you sign up — an idea it has gradually expanded on as it opens up to more and more people in the U.S. and around the world.

Now, put yourself in the mind of the average user in another country. You’re joining because you want to hang out with friends around you, or maybe friends who have immigrated to other countries, or maybe you want to meet new people in other countries because you’re human and you’re curious about people in general.

Let’s say a friend who lives near you invites you to join. You see your friend’s real information, you mimic that by providing your own. You start using the site and you see that basically most other users have also added their real information, confirming that you should continue to provide real information on the site. Facebook also asks you to join a local network — which most new users seem to do — and you immediately get access to a bunch of other people a lot like you.

Now, let’s say you start looking around the site. You go to the profile page of a worldwide icon like English soccer club Manchester United, and see real users from around the world leaving comments. Or say you’re using a flirting application and start flirting with real people, also from around the world. In either case, you friend these people because you find you have something in common with them, and would like to see their full profiles (on Facebook, you normally have to either friend people or be in their network to see their full profiles). They friend you back, and pretty soon you, the new user, has a large Facebook friend list that gives you a direct view into who people really are, everywhere.

Facebook users in many Middle Eastern countries and Facebook users in the US have been busy making friends and overcoming larger political and religious differences, as Facebook chief executive Mark Zuckerberg has noted — and as I have personally seen.

Meanwhile, join MySpace, and you’ll encounter bewildering user profile pages dedicated to sub-segments of American pop culture that you don’t understand or care about, that won’t help you easily find old friends and new ones. Even though it lets you state things like what school you’re in and where you live within your user profile, the site didn’t grow based on these definitions, and beyond American high school users on the site, local networks are weak-to-nonexistent.

Blogger Andrew Chen noted the culture issue in an April post looking at Facebook’s worldwide growth rate, although he attributed the difference more generally to Facebook’s relatively simple, “utilitarian” interface and not to the distinct user behavior that the interface and site evolution have together bred.

So, in this context, Facebook’s growth and MySpace’s lack thereof may help explain why MySpace is launching a new, cleaner interface, which you can read about here. However, the changes, which include simpler site navigation options at the top of the site, better search, and more options for profile editing, don’t appear to impact how users perceive the site.

MySpace will likely continue to be a leading social networking destination, especially for people looking mainly for self-expression. It, and other social networks, have already ceded the real world to Facebook, though, and I don’t see them doing anything to change that.

Okay, so what are all these users worth


Social network advertising — which is generally comprised of ineffectively targeted banner ads — isn’t making that much money, and so far, neither have virtual gifts and various other monetization ideas. MySpace has had more trouble making money than it had hoped, as it made slightly less than the billion it was aiming for this past year. However, it’s shown promising progress in targeting ads to users based on user’s own profile data (example: If you’re a MySpace user who likes shoes, you’re more likely to see ads for shoes).

Facebook, which is valued at $15 billion, expects to make up to $350 million this year, but that’s at least offset by costs incurred through its growth. It has been looking at fleshing out everything from targeted ads to video ads.

But the fact that monetization methods for social networks haven’t fully evolved yet is no reason to view this segment pessimistically. Web market analysis firm eMarketer released a report last month in which it revised long-term revenue projections for social network advertising downwards from its earlier report. But the report is based on what the firm’s analysts read in the press and what they hear from companies. A large chunk of the projections dip is likely based on the one-off report about MySpace not meeting its own high expectations

With the vast majority of social network revenues coming from US users (it’s currently the most lucrative advertising market in the world), it goes without saying that social network companies are dependent on growing out their US user bases quickly.

And MySpace might be right to focus so heavily on the U.S. market for now. On the other hand, entrepreneurship involves taking risks to be early to new markets and nail them before your competitors. There are plenty of economies currently growing much faster than the U.S.’s, and as social networks catch on in those countries, social network advertising will grow. So, gaining a global user base now is actually a land-grab among social networks, especially for the largest social networks, all of which have substantial funding to back them up as they continue to grow.

If you were a social network, would you want tens of millions of international users now, even if you figure you probably won’t make money on them for years? I would.

[Comscore image via Techcrunch.]

Tags: , ,
Trackback URL

  1. June 13th, 2008
    5:44 pm

    Facebook和Myspace的不同,与Facebook的(部分)超越 | SilenceWolf said:

    [...] 好了,这两段翻译完了,这篇文章接下来回顾了facebook在校园当中的原始状态,人们是如何需要在这里建立他们真实的信息和朋友关系。以及,facebook的海外用户与美国本土用户的不同。可以在这里继续阅读。 [...]

  2. June 14th, 2008
    2:54 am

    Why Facebook is now the number one social network in the world … - VentureBeat | Pat McGraw said:

    [...] and Facebook and why Facebook is experiencing greater success on the global stage.  Source: VentureBeat) “At first we were worried about MySpace, but then we realized that people use it differently [...]

  3. June 14th, 2008
    7:39 pm

    Why Facebook is now the number one social network in the world … - Celebrity Gossip pictures and news said:

    [...] admin wrote an interesting post today on Why Facebook is now the number one social network in the world ……Here’s a quick excerpt:Meanwhile, rival MySpace is more of a place for people to live out their fantasy lives online, borrowing luminary photos for their profile cinemas, adding far-fetched biographical information and such — MySpace uses the designate … [...]

  4. June 15th, 2008
    2:17 am

    Facebook alive and kicking « GCI Stockholm said:

    [...] är i stället utanför USA som Facebook växer mest, inte minst i Europa. VentureBeat analyserar här utvecklingen och funderar kring vad det betyder för dem som använder sociala nätverk för sin [...]

  5. June 18th, 2008
    1:27 pm

    Hitwise: Facebook gaining on MySpace in the US » VentureBeat said:

    [...] grew 42 percent this may over last, seemingly at MySpace’s expense. See graph below for more. As I recently argued, Facebook’s advantage appears to be that it captures real-world relationships in a way that [...]

  6. June 19th, 2008
    5:51 am

    canada white pages said:

    [...] me over a year ago. What he meant is that Facebook is a place for people to put their real liveshttp://venturebeat.com/2008/06/13/why-facebook-is-now-the-number-one-social-network-in-the-world-and…Are They Really Oil Wars? Payvand Iran NewsA most widely-cited factor behind the recent U.S. wars of [...]

  7. June 19th, 2008
    12:03 pm

    hi5 search said:

    [...] me over a year ago. What he meant is that Facebook is a place for people to put their real liveshttp://venturebeat.com/2008/06/13/why-facebook-is-now-the-number-one-social-network-in-the-world-and…Qloud Launches My Music Application on MySpace Broadcast NewsroomWASHINGTON , June 3 /PRNewswire/ — [...]

  8. June 23rd, 2008
    9:43 am

    The real market value of social networks: Facebook may still rule » VentureBeat said:

    [...] There is strong evidence Facebook users enjoy higher income levels than those of MySpace, because Facebook started among those who attended top universities. Advertisers may be more willing to target Facebook’s users than MySpace’s users. VentureBeat’s Eric Eldon wrote about this recently, and provided other reasons why Facebook’s network is mor…. [...]

  9. June 25th, 2008
    5:41 pm

    Why Facebook Is Now The #1 Social Network In The World | popFAIL said:

    [...] read more | digg story | popfail [...]

  10. June 26th, 2008
    12:38 pm

    Social Networks: Censory Overload… My Head is Starting to Hurt | said:

    [...] Why Facebook is now the number one social network in the world and why this matters. VentureBeat, great blog covering startup news in different sectors. Provides cultural analysis on how Facebook is different from other social nets, why it has a high adoption rate in all countries so far and the value/future value of Facebook users. All of these blog posts are insightful and there is something to be learned from all of them. However, I feel there is a lot of over-thinking going on with regards to the discussion about the actual valuation of these companies, and I believe many of the bloggers sited above would agree. The social networking phenomenon itself is not an idea that will either sink or swim in the next 5-10 years as some people seem to believe. Some of the players in this space will execute on making money off of the massive amounts of traffic they receive and some will not. It is clear and inevitable that, like in any industry, the different players will need to develop competitive advantages (as they already have began to do) and focus on a certain industry that social actions online can integrate with - this comes down to being more than just ’social networks’. [...]

  11. June 28th, 2008
    11:02 pm

    space pictures said:

    [...] friends. Meanwhile, rival MySpace is more of a place for people to live out their fantasy liveshttp://venturebeat.com/2008/06/13/why-facebook-is-now-the-number-one-social-network-in-the-world-and…Astronomy Picture of the Day Archive2008 April 01: New space Station Robot Asks to be Called Dextre [...]

  12. June 30th, 2008
    6:56 am

    make money with google said:

    make money with google…

    Great post! Looking forward to many more……

  13. July 10th, 2008
    4:29 pm

    Another key early Facebook employee, Jeff Hammerbacher, is leaving the company » VentureBeat said:

    [...] Facebook may now be the largest social network in the world, and it may be continually innovating with nice new products like its Twitter-like iPhone application, but more and more beloved early employees are heading out the door. The latest rumor I’ve heard is that the head of the company’s data analysis team, Jeff Hammerbacher, has given his final notice. Facebook has confirmed. [...]

  14. ComScore: Social networks, especially Facebook, still getting big around the world » VentureBeat said:

    [...] Facebook has rocketed up 153 percent to 132 million, a trend we’ve been covering for months; others, like hi5, have also done well, having grown 100 percent to 56 million. MySpace, however, [...]

  15. Chain « Strickly Speaking said:

    [...] is, though, the phrase most used to describe the Facebook phenomenon.  A recent article reported that Facebook is the number one social network site in the world.  In just a span of [...]