More open government: Obama transition site Change.gov gets user comments

Change.gov, president-elect Barack Obama’s web site covering his administration’s transition to the White House, now lets users share their feedback about the U.S. health care system. Since this new page of the site launched yesterday, asking the provocative question “What worries you most about the health care system in our country?” it has garnered well over 2,000 comments.

This is a great early step in making government more open — a long-standing promise of Obama’s, and an ideal that I believe needs to be practically integrated into his administration from the get-go in order to be effective. It’s also a boost for the OpenID web-wide user identification initiative, but more on that below. The next step, of course, is how the administration will use the comments to actually implement policy. Obama doesn’t take office until January, so one step at a time. He used social networking to his advantage during his campaign, and after being elected has begun doing things like posting weekly address videos on YouTube.

Most commenters seem to be serious types, from the quick look I’ve had. But they can also be anonymous, so I’m surprised the comment trolls haven’t struck yet; quite likely, moderators are at work and already quite busy.

The other angle here is that the site is using comment plugin IntenseDebate, a service that provides a range of additional features like threads for related comments, voting on comments, and more. Intense Debate was recently purchased by blog platform company Wordpress, which no doubt gave it added legitimacy when the administration chose which plugin to use. (VentureBeat, in a sharp break with the Obama administration’s policy on this major issue, uses comment plugin rival Disqus. See below.)

Meanwhile, IntenseDebate uses an open identification standard called OpenID, that aims to let users sign into any site using pre-existing identities on other sites. I was able to sign in to comment on Change.gov using my Wordpress.com username through Intense Debate’s implementation of OpenID. The concept of OpenID has seemed a bit too abstract, in my opinion, for the average user to understand. But Change.gov is giving both IntenseDebate and OpenID a big publicity boost. And it’s also using OpenID more openly than the service’s other partner sites. As ReadWriteWeb’s Marshall Kirkpatrick notes:

Every other major player that has announced support for OpenID has in fact only allowed accounts with their company to be used as an OpenID elsewhere — they have not allowed other OpenIDs to be used to log in to their own sites. That means Barack Obama is cooler than AOL, MySpace, Google (except for Blogger.com comments) and Yahoo!. Maybe you already knew that, though.

Bookmark and Share

Tags: , ,

Photo of Eric Eldon

About the Author, Eric Eldon

Eric currently covers digital media technology and business, especially what's happening on social networks and their platforms. He writes and edits stories about lots of other stuff, too. He started at VentureBeat in the spring of 2007, half a year or so after Matt Marshall left his reporting job at the San Jose Mercury News to found the site. Eric previously cofounded a now-failed startup called Writewith, that was building editorial software for newspapers and other groups of writers.

  • He's truly the President 2.0. Let us hope that all the user input gets consolidated into actions that can be acted up by the new team. A true model for every local government to emulate. Lets wait and see how long it takes others to follow through. I definitely have a lot to suggest to the San Jose local government and would love an easier way to do so.
  • Excellent post.

    The 2thinknow View would be that engagement is a modern version of "Big Block of Cheese Day", referencing President Jackson on the West Wing.

    Or the more open door of presidents like Lincoln.

    Social media & the Web enable citizens to engage in the policy process. Node to node. That's the 2thinknow view.

    Sam from 2thinknow.
  • It is fantastic to see an interactive blog with comments for such a distinguished usage! Intense Debate is one of the best services, along with Disqus and Js-kit, that will encourage greater web based discussion.
  • Yes, Barack Obama is certain way more generous towards OpenID than the internet giants like Yahoo, AOL or even Google who all choose to serve as OpenID providers instead of trying to help the concept of single ID for all websites.
  • Millie Haborak
    Help people who are having a problem paying their mortgage. Pay down half of their mortgage (50%). Then we will have money to put back in the economy. Instead of bailing out all of these giants. How about helping the middle class?.
  • Florenz A. Wiegmann
    I read somewhere that Taiwan has one of the best universal healthcare systems in the world and the administration cost is 5%. Have you looked at their system?
  • Obamauser
    If only IntenseDebate actually worked, it might be useful to comment on change.gov. But it's a mess -- you can't find your own postings, so people re-post a lot; you can't search, there are 2000+ comments and you drown in irrelevant crap which it won't collapse out or filter.
  • Isaria
    Please stop ptting fluoride in the drinking water.This will save Billions of dollars!!
    The educational system needs to be two fold! There should be an Academic Line & a Trades Line to accomodate students who want a college education as well as those who want a trade.
  • Please stop ptting fluoride in the drinking water.This will save Billions of dollars!!