Facebook wants you to give credit where credit is due

Facebook is testing out a way for people to show how much they appreciate friends’ status updates, links and other items on the site — its a new feature called “credits.” The idea is a more advanced form of commenting or liking an item on the site — and if it works, it could spur people to share more information that they think their friends will enjoy (and give them credits for).

While the concept is still undergoing changes, here’s how it works at this time.

When you leave a comment on an item, you’ll see a field where you can enter the number of credits you want to give the person who created the item. You’ll also see the number of credits you have available to give — you can choose to give up to the number of credits you possess. You can only get credits by buying them in Facebook’s virtual gifts store — $1 for 100 credits — or by receiving them (or by getting some free when you start using credits, although Facebook is testing how many to make available that way).

Once you’ve left a comment with credits, you’ll see the credits appear next to the comment, following the feature’s green plus symbol icon. There’s no other way to create credits at this time. This means people need to think twice before giving their credits away.

Once you have credits, you can use them to give them away, or to buy Facebook’s virtual gifts.

In fact, the notion grew out of Facebook’s virtual gifts feature, as gifts-and-credits product manager Jared Morgenstern tells me. When it’s somebody’s birthday on Facebook, you can just leave a wall post, or if you want to go out of your way to show how much you care, you can give them a free or for-fee virtual gifts that will appear on their profile page. In the same way, giving someone credits shows that you’ve gone out of your way to show you much you care about what they’re sharing.

So its more like a gift and less like a virtual currency of the sort that you see in games, and less like buying virtual clothes to decorate an avatar. Competitive gaming features are de-emphasized. For example, there’s no leaderboard that shows you who on the site or among your friends has the most credits. You can only see how many credits you have when you’re looking to give them to somebody else or when you’re in the gift store. Your credit, er, score doesn’t even show up on your profile page. You can’t even see the total number of credits that people have together given a particular item.

Why does this matter for Facebook? The company could potentially use information about what items people are giving credits to in order to figure out which items to put in its new “highlights” section on its homepage (although it’s not right now). Credits can also show Facebook much deeper information about what people think of each other. If you’re constantly crediting back and forth with a few friends, for example, Facebook would learn that you all care a lot about what each other have to say.

Right now, the service is being tested out on 15 US college networks on Facebook, within Facebook’s own company network, and most recently on VentureBeat’s company network. At the moment, Facebook is expanding the test by letting credit possessors give credit to those without, and thereby letting them access the feature. It will be rolled out more if it shows itself to be having the intended effect; so far it’s doing well, Morganstern tells me. The company may also at some point offer a filter so you can see items that friends are crediting.

One can imagine the feature expanding in all sorts of directions — through Facebook Connect, for example. People who leave comments on VentureBeat using their Facebook identity could one day show how much they liked a post by giving it credits that show up in VentureBeat comments.

Next Story: TomTom to track traffic, weather, gas prices in real time
Previous Story: Microsoft’s second “Laptop Hunter” commercial airs tomorrow sans Lauren

Bookmark and Share

Tags:

Photo of Eric Eldon

About the Author, Eric Eldon

Eric currently covers digital media technology and business news, especially what's happening on social networks and their platforms. He also writes and edits stories about venture capital, and lots of other stuff, too. He started at VentureBeat in the spring of 2007, half a year or so after Matt Marshall left his reporting job at the San Jose Mercury News to found the site. Eric previously cofounded a startup called Writewith, that was building editorial software for newspapers and other groups of writers. The startup didn't work out, but he learned a lot.

  • yep
    eric eldon is attractive.
  • I'll give you 10 credits on behalf of eric for that comment.
  • true that
    He's even better looking in person.
  • Maybe this could be a micropayments scheme for other Facebook apps?
  • Good point. I'd asked Facebook about that but they replied that it's
    too early to say where the feature is headed. So maybe?
  • Hutch Carpenter
    +1 bdude
  • MySpace kudos, but more awesome, in other words.
  • Facebook User
    Thanks Eric, +73.
  • I appreciate that Facebook is trying something cute like this to make money, but honestly, is this the best they could do? Once someone has credits, they can give them away or buy virtual crap for someone else? Or, we could all just not waste our time sending pennies back and forth.

    Integrating actual micropayments for real & virtual goods and services would be far more lucrative in the long run. My friends on facebook are the people that I have casual debts with. Why not let me settle my burrito tab the next morning with one click on Facebook?
  • igniman
    Do they plan to allow third party apps to access this credits stream? it would be a very lucrative source if facebook opened it up and shared profits with developers
  • would be cool if they inverted it, or used "like" datamining to generate a digg killer (most credited links, people, et. al)
  • Actually testing a new feature with users? That doesn't sound like Facebook at all.
  • With all the apps on Facebook, it would be great to get credit for your efforts. But ... I am wondering what igniman asked above ... "Do they plan to allow third party apps to access this credits stream?" I have to agree and agree to sharing my info with apps on every site I'm on. I am beginning to feel like I'm spread out all over the internet now.
  • Niels
    ugh.. this really sounds like a delayed april Fool's joke..

    Fall 2007 Fbook supposedly talked about micropayments w 3rd party app devs and April 2009 we see a field-test of credits for status updates or ..wait.. now I get it: Soon you can attach credits to friend request and - viola - we have a real economy for facebook users to earn credits by buying and selling friendship; it's brilliant it's.. it's... it's "Friends For Sale".. ugh.
  • it would be better if we could also take credits from each other for uninteresting posts...

    news feed

    john doe has extra concert tickets to give away to the first person to respond to this.
    +10

    john smith loves his family.
    -5

    jane doe is.
    -20
  • patricianoble
    Why are you using the company's jargon about credits instead of plain speaking to your readers?
  • I'd be very hesitant about using something like this.

    My overall problem is --- what happens if the recipient doesn't spend the credits? Is this like the "gift card" or "travelers checks" or "rebates" process where companies make as much (or more) money on the un-redeemed items as they do on the actual product.

    I for one would not use this unless there was a bigger benefit to spending it -- for example you actually gifted some type of item or extended feature and not just "credits".
  • i like that they are experimenting. but not a fan of the walled garden approach. be better if they integrated their own version of paypal.

    it also somewhat reminds me of a project i started in 2006 called fundavlog and started a blog at crowdfunding.com to log development of the idea. i had implemented a paypal powered credit system and added a feature right along with comments and ratings (on each videoblog post) that let users add as many pennies/credits as they could. one-click allowed for incrementing pennies or dollar amounts. the recipient of funds could cash out all or some of their money or leave it in the 'bank' so they can reciprocate by giving to others.

    no fees were taken as the way i implemented paypal avoided any transaction costs. so instead, i was going to rely on the community donating funds to the project itself to help pay for hosting or just tip for development time etc.

    it was a project in social capitalism and self-sustaining community of video creators via the concept of what i called crowdfunding.

    real job/life prevented continued development , however.
  • Winston
    Can you name the school networks that are in the test?
  • Facebook User
    Can I have, like, a ba-jillion credits? Thanks.
  • I know personally I'm not going to buy credits just to give them away.
  • credits, just like twitter Twollars http://twollars.com only for Facebook.
  • I wonder how far we are from Facebook charging for use (commenting, liking, posting) through a credit-based system. It'll probably never happen since it would cut out much of the social growth, but I wonder if a micropayment-based charge-for-activity niche network (perhaps one tying together buyers and sellers and not just "friends") is that far away...
  • I study complementary currencies since nov/2003 and I'm happy to see some companies starting "to print" your own money. While some few people, beneficiaries of a glut of money, believing that wealth is money, others are creating money, maybe, by believing that is possible to create money to share out the real wealth of our communities that are our talent in form of products and services. Viva Facebook :)
  • ithink,while these credits will attract people to facebook, Iwonder about the lifespan, given that facebook is yet to turn a profit
  • this is the new way of the dot com,

    i think last.fm is a pioneer in the age on profit.... facebook will become a child???

    i hope no.
  • asimkhan
    Facebooks pathetic attempt to make money in a recession will fail. Just like Ebay has failed and so many before it. Trying to make money off others while not actually putting in any physical effort never achieves the desired result !