BumpTop gives Windows desktop a much-needed makeover

Microsoft’s Windows desktop isn’t nearly as efficient at using space as a real desktop. That’s what Anand Agarawala concluded more than five years ago, when he began to study ways to create a better user interface for the screen that computer users stare at all day long.

Today, he’s launching BumpTop, a downloadable software program that overlays Microsoft’s various Windows operating systems — XP, Vista and the upcoming Windows 7. It turns your desktop into a kind of 3-D view, where you can stack icons or similar-looking files together. You can grab icons with your mouse — or, with Windows 7, your own fingers via a touch screen — and toss all of your photos or documents into a pile. Since it appears to have a vertical dimension but the viewpoint doesn’t change, it’s called “2.5-D” instead of true 3-D. Full 3-D is possible, but it can be very disorienting for users who aren’t accustomed to it.

“We feel we’re overdue for a fresh approach to the desktop,” Agarawala said in an interview. “It’s too easy for desktop items to be lost or forgotten. The interface is impersonal and rigid.”

BumpTop could be a more productive use of Windows real estate because it’s just like your regular desk. You can stack piles of similar things on top of each other, allowing you to view at a glance a broader group of items than you can with the two-dimensional view that Windows offers you.

Agarawala, 27, (right) started work on BumpTop for his master’s thesis. He graduated in 2006 and turned the project into a real company in Toronto in 2007. He presented the idea publicly at the TED conference in early 2007, stirring up a lot of interest. He received funding from as-yet-unnamed sources and hired 10 people to turn it into a product.

It could gain traction in part because Microsoft has left a gigantic opening for rival desktop interfaces. The Windows interface is mostly two-dimensional and hasn’t changed dramatically in a long time. With Windows Vista, the company explored a lot of 3-D concepts but, even with 10,000 people working on the project, it ultimately retreated and trashed most of the ideas.

One of the surviving features was the unsatisfying Windows Flip 3D feature, which let you look at a bunch of web pages with a 3-D view as if you were flipping through a circular Rolodex. That feature required more memory and a decent 3-D graphics card to run properly.

BumpTop can get by with a 1.4-gigahertz processor, a gigahertz of main memory, and an integrated graphics card. Those components aren’t necessarily all that demanding. But if you have lots of items on your desktop, it will slow down and choke on the processing task. It’s better to use a machine with a dedicated 3-D graphics processor.

One rival, besides Microsoft itself, is SpaceTime 3D, which created a web browser that could present web pages in 3-D (above, right) so that you could see more pages at the same time. But SpaceTime 3D isn’t as customizable as BumpTop.

Another rival is Jeff Han’s Perceptive Pixel company, which has a futuristic user interface built into touch-screen flat panels. Han’s technology has been showcased on CNN, which used the touch-screen interface to display maps on election night. But the technology is still expensive. Microsoft has its own Surface tabletop touch-controlled user interface, but those machines are also very expensive now.

So BumpTop’s arrival as a free application could be very timely. With BumpTop, you can use a pen, fingers, or mouse to “throw” a document on a wall or scrawl a sticky note and make it big enough to remind you of an important task. You can also toss a memo onto the desk of a colleague who is also running BumpTop. When you look at a pile, you can right click to bring up a circular menu and then choose a view, such as fanning out the items in the pile, to make it easier to see what’s there.

The interface also accommodates social networks. You can upload photos simply by tossing them at the Facebook, Twitter or Flickr icons on the walls of your desktop. You can email or print a document simply by tossing it on top of the email or printer icons.

As you can see from the pictures, you can post things on the walls surrounding the flat part of the BumpTop interface. You can make any document, app or photo grow or shrink. The more you use something, the bigger its icon becomes on the desktop. You can decorate the walls as you like.

So far, 30,000 or so users have been testing it for as long as a year. Some have created their own custom desktop themes that others can use. Agarawala said the company is in talks with computer makers to see if they will include it in upcoming models.

Over time, the company will phase in new features and introduce a premium $29 version. That will include live support and features such as the ability to move items to a univeral serial bus flash memory drive by tossing documents onto a USB icon. Right now, it doesn’t work on a Mac. But the Mac OS already incorporates plenty of 3-D features and so isn’t in as desperate need of a makeover as Windows.

The company’s investors include GrowthWorks, Extreme Venture Partners, and three angels: Andy Hertzfeld, Austin Hill, and G.R. Heffernan Associates.

Next Story:
Previous Story:

Tags: ,

Photo of Dean Takahashi

About the Author, Dean Takahashi

Dean is lead writer for GamesBeat at VentureBeat. He covers video games, security, chips and a variety of other subjects. Dean previously worked at the San Jose Mercury News, the Wall Street Journal, the Red Herring, the Los Angeles Times, the Orange County Register and the Dallas Times Herald. He is the author of two books, Opening the Xbox and the Xbox 360 Uncloaked. Follow him on Twitter at @deantak, and follow VentureBeat on Twitter at @venturebeat.

  • Congrats to Anand & the Bumptop team. This is such a great accomplishment. I met Anand at TED and was an immediate fan of his vision.

    I quickly became part of those "as-yet-unnamed sources of funding" so I'm excited to see it launch.

    This is only the beginning, lot's of exciting things coming from the Bumptop team.
  • Aaron deMello
    Really great stuff... I believe these guys are in Canada as well, which is wonderful. Can't wait for the Mac version, although to tell the truth - Windows needs more help. ;-)
  • Aaron deMello
    "BumpTop can get by with a 1.4-gigahertz processor, a gigahertz of main memory, and an integrated graphics card. "


    Dean, I think you mean a gigabyte of main memory.
  • yo mama
    much-needed? Vista is light years ahead of anything else when it comes to looks.
  • Patrice Breton
    BumpTop is fresh and exciting. Congratulations!

    PS: Would be fun to play with the desktop view angle.
  • With respect to the people behind this who are clearly smarter than I am -- and I say that without sarcasm -- this is destined for the museum of fail. The desktop metaphor starts to fall apart almost immediately as the amount of information grows. A 3-D version of a poor interface is just that much less effective.

    The most widely used method for organizing and accessing information is clearly search. Remember the Yahoo directory? Me either. A 2-D or 3-D graphical version of manually organized information isn't much different.

    Disorganized but searchable information is by the most common and useful kind -- by several orders of magnitude. Google Desktop and its Microsoft and Apple equivalents, backed by necessarily limited GUIs, are the future.
  • This looks really cool. Pretty good with options to Twitter, Facebook, Sticky notes and Email.
    3D desktop already available in Linux. But it's good to see in windows
  • "But the Mac OS already incorporates plenty of 3-D features and so isn’t in as desperate need of a makeover as Windows."


    Wait, what? The Mac OS doesn't have a single 3D feature on the desktop.

    Beyond being blatantly wrong, that comment adds nothing to the article. BumpTop would be just as welcome on the Mac as it is on Windows. If you want to know why there isn't a Mac version yet, you should ask the developers - I doubt they're going to say "because the Mac doesn't need it."
  • Anom Pasi
    Welcome to 2000 Anand,

    Virtual 3D desktop interfaces have been around since 1999 as a Windows 95 THEMEs!!!.

    yeah, it may not have been popular, but it was there.

    There is nothing special that you have done.
  • I don't think software like this is necessary because most computer users nowadays know how to organize their files and there's a lot of software alike out there which is much better than this.
  • bob
    CALLING MICROSOFT BOB. ARE YOU THERE? BOB! HELLO?

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Bob

    We all know how *that* turned out... Don't people ever learn from history?
  • 1.21 GigaWATTS
    This is awesome! Now I just need to find out where to buy a gigahertz of main system memory.
  • Hmmm
    Does anyone edit these articles? "...a gigahertz of main memory" - my laptop only has 4 GB of memory, not nearly a gigahertz. And why didn't you link to or embed the video from the BumpTop site, which does a much better job of describing the features and benefits than this article does?
  • fail
    destined for fail....agreed.
  • Funky
    link to bumptop download page in article please, yes I know google toolbar, but I'm lazy.
  • Jason
    I agree with PluckyGlen Ford.

    I installed this program and it lasted about 10 minutes. Look, companies like Apple and MS spend 1000 of man years and millions upon millions of dollars to create usable user interfaces. BumpTop does not seems to take advantage of any of the features in the modern UI. To me it looks like a step backwards. Its just another one of the funny 3d things that we happen on every now and again.
    Dont get me wrong its a nice technical achievement and the guy must be pleased with his work. It just that this program (as the jobs link on the site states) is not going to "change the world"

    Jason

    ps. note to developer of this program. I suggest you remove the statement about changing the world on your jobs page. Its ridiculous. You have written a nice little program, you are not changing anything especially "the world"
  • Patrice Breton
    Boy ... talk about a tough crowd. There is definitely something different here. And it's nothing like Msft BOB (!).

    This being said, the update won't install, it crashes too often and the 3D gives it a toy feel ... which is not for me. But I love it .... dynamic experience and natural feel. It's staying on for now.
  • I also second PluckyGlen Ford. Why do people stick to the "desktop" analogy, pushing it to adapt to the obvious disadvantages of the physical desktop?
    Firefox innovated the information management with the awesomebar, with all the others following in their next versions. Clearly, this was the way to go with bookmarks and browser history, why not with the rest of your data? People will adapt to a command line interface if it's smart, and if you don't tell them it's a cli :-)
    Disclaimer: I haven't tried Google Desktop.
blog comments powered by Disqus