‘Separating the men from the boys’ in Government 2.0

Updated

Everyone knows the internet is critical to getting elected nowadays, especially after it played a crucial role in President Obama’s success. But you need to do more than just throw up a Facebook page and a Twitter account, said Obama campaign advisor/Twitter investor Chris Sacca (pictured on the left). At last night’s Startup2Startup event on “Government 2.0,” Sacca told the crowd that politicians shouldn’t just think of online social networking tools as “yet another proxy for advertising.”

“That’s what’s separating the men from the boys now,” he said. “Are you actually going to participate in the conversation?”

So who’s doing it right? Of course, everyone likes to talk about Obama — in the words of Facebook’s Randi Zuckerberg, his campaign was “really run like a tech company.” She recalled attending the Democratic National Convention and being besieged by politicians and activists interested in using Facebook, then going to the Republican National Convention and “[sitting] alone in my room for three days.” [Update: In the comments below, the Republican National Convention's Matt Burns takes issue with Zuckerberg's portrayal of the RNC.]

But YouTube’s news and political director Steve Grove (pictured, right) argued that some of Obama’s advantage came from being the challenger, giving him more freedom to experiment and motivating more people to get involved. That underdog spirit may be helping Republicans now, he said. For example, on YouTube’s page for the U.S. Congress, videos from Republicans are now more popular than those from Democrats. And Sacca acknowledged that some of the Obama administration’s social media efforts since taking office have been rather underwhelming.

You can check out a full video of the event below the jump. (Don’t listen too loudly at work, though, because there’s a lot of profanity.) Meanwhile, I’ll let panel moderator Dave McClure of the Founders Fund have the last word. After Grove described Obama using YouTube to wish Iranians a “Happy Nowruz” (the Iranian New Year) as “interesting,” McClure responded:

That’s not interesting, that is earth-shattering. The fact that we have a black man in the White House with a Muslim name saying “Happy Nowruz” to the Iranian people — that is f—ing astonishing. … I cannot believe the change that we have experienced in less than 12 months.

[photo:flickr/NandorFejer]

Next Story:
Previous Story:

Tags: , , , , , ,

Photo of Anthony Ha

About the Author, Anthony Ha

Anthony is VentureBeat's assistant editor, as well as its reporter on enterprise technology, cloud computing, and tech policy. Before joining VentureBeat in 2008, Anthony worked at the Hollister Free Lance, where he won awards from the California Newspaper Publishers Association for breaking news coverage and writing. He attended Stanford University and now lives in San Francisco. Reach him at anthony@venturebeat.com. You can also follow Anthony on Twitter.

  • It looks to me that all this social media is viewed by politicians only as the trendy means to an end. Once the goal is accomplished (e.g. being elected) twitter and co is barely being utilized anymore. Until the next election. Quite a shame because they could provide the platform for true interactive government. Maybe someday - with web 3.0?
  • There's some truth to that, but I think the Obama administration is making other efforts too, such as Data.gov.
  • I had an opportunity to speak to Republican and Democrat Hill staffers a few weeks ago. Topic was blogging and microcontent. It was interesting to me that in the Republican session, it definitely seemed like the staffers were interested in the how's, what's and where's... They asked questions about how they could best serve their bosses in this brave new world.

    Democrats, to my surprise, were far more interested in ethics and franking rules. They were concerned about the integrity of journalism when the topic came up about media relations. They did seem to project a sense of caring more about the mechanics of the stuff. The GOP seemed to capture the energy and passion of the medium. It was odd.
  • Matt Burns
    With all due respect, Randi Zuckerberg is totally full of sh*t on this one – at least as her comments relate to the Republican National Convention.

    As the Director of Communications for the convention, I can tell you we worked closely with Google/YouTube, Ustream.tv, Microsoft, and countless other companies to create a comprehensive and successful online campaign. Those efforts were recently recognized with five “Pollie Awards” from The Association of Political and Public Affairs Professionals. And we utilized Facebook – even if it wasn’t up to Ms. Zuckerberg’s standards – as part of our overall strategy.

    Is it possible Ms. Zuckerberg sat alone in her hotel room during the Republican National Convention because she never actually contacted anyone? Or maybe she forgot about the major hurricane barreling toward the Gulf Coast on the eve of the Republican National Convention? Or maybe she didn't really want to be around a group of conservative Americans in the first place?

    According to the Wall Street Journal: “'At the Democratic convention we were like rock stars,' Zuckerberg said Thursday to a conference crowd of what could safely be called Democratic-leaning entrepreneurs and investors."

    Wait. Ms. Zuckerberg bashed Republicans while speaking to an audience of her liberal friends? Shocker!

    In all seriousness, can Ms. Zuckerberg tell us what the Democratic National Convention did with Facebook – aside from pet their enlarged egos and take them to glitzy parties with the Hollywood elite – that Republican National Convention planners didn't?

    I guess next time we won't make the mistake of letting the business of nominating our Presidential candidate get in the way of the folks at Facebook being treated like rock stars.

    Apologies to Facebook. Our bad.

    Matt Burns
    Director of Communications
    2008 Republican National Convention
    mattaburns@gmail.com
  • Thanks for your perspective, Matt. I'll add an update to my post pointing to your comment.
blog comments powered by Disqus