Business

Apple buys Lala. Can any music startup eke out a return for investors?

NOTE: GrowthBeat -- VentureBeat's provocative new marketing-tech event -- is next week! We've gathered the best and brightest to explore the data, apps, and science of successful marketing. Get the full scoop here, and grab your tickets while they last.

So Apple did the deed. It bought streaming music startup Lala.

AllThingsD’s Peter Kafka says it was done at a valuation reflecting Warner Music Group’s writedown earlier this spring, which means investors are lucky to get 50 cents on the dollar. The New York Times also reported that the sale was prompted by realization that Lala’s prospects for profitability in the near future were dim. This makes Lala the third music startup this fall to be acquired at a breakeven or loss to investors, after iLike and Imeem were bought by MySpace.

Music is extraordinarily difficult. The going rate for streaming is around a half-cent per play, and any startup eager to break into the space must confront the four major record labels in the U.S., who demand a pound of flesh usually in equity and an upfront payment worth millions of dollars. This means you too, Spotify. (Hence, the much-ballyhooed Swedish startup’s $50 million round involving Hong Kong billionaire Li Ka-shing this fall.)

So what does Apple get out of the deal? Lala’s streaming contracts expire in the event of an acquisition, so scratch that off the list. The buy could help Apple kill an emerging competitor, or bring in Lala’s engineering talent to build some streaming functionality into iTunes. Or Apple could be buying it to keep it out of the hands of another mobile operator or manufacturer like Nokia, that would want to offer streaming content to customers.

The normally chatty founder Bill Nguyen and his team aren’t talking to the public. He spoke publicly earlier this fall when Lala secured a deal with Facebook to offer song streaming on the social network in the form of virtual gifts. Lala has scored a few promising deals this fall, including Google’s music search service.


We're studying digital marketing compensation: how much companies pay CMOs, CDOs, VPs of marketing, and more, with ChiefDigitalOfficer. Help us out by filling out the survey, and we'll share the results with you.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] note, signed by Color CEO Bill Nguyen (founder of Lala, the music service acquired in 2009 by Apple), announced: “Color is opening [...]

  2. [...] note, signed by Color CEO Bill Nguyen (founder of Lala, the music service acquired in 2009 by Apple), announced: “Color is opening soon!” In March, many people who tried Color ended up [...]

  3. [...] note, signed by Color CEO Bill Nguyen (founder of Lala, the music service acquired in 2009 by Apple), announced: “Color is opening [...]

  4. [...] leadership team included the likes of co-founder and chief executive Bill Nguyen (founder of Lala, the music service acquired in 2009 by Apple), co-founder and president Peter Pham (formerly CEO of BillShrink) and Patil. Pham left Color in [...]

  5. [...] team at one point included the likes of co-founder and chief executive Bill Nguyen (founder of Lala, the music service acquired in 2009 by Apple), co-founder and president Peter Pham (formerly CEO of BillShrink) and Patil. Pham left Color in [...]

  6. [...] former care group enclosed a likes of co-founder and arch executive Bill Nguyen (founder of Lala, a song use acquired in 2009 by Apple), co-founder and boss Peter Pham (formerly CEO of BillShrink) and Patil. Pham left Color in [...]

  7. [...] But there’s another, more crazy possibility here as well: Color Labs could have been acquired by Apple, as the Next Web reports. (Not new to acquiring the brain children of Color CEO Bill Nguyen, Apple purchased  music service Lala for $80 million in 2009.) [...]