Caving to censors, Craigslist takes down its controversial adult services

Evidently caving to pressure from law enforcement and politicians, online ad site Craigslist has taken down the Adult Services section of its site.

The adult services section has now been replaced by a black and white “censored” word, which cannot be clicked upon.

With that one word, pictured below, Craigslist is clearly making a statement. But in shutting the section down it is also proving that it cannot operate a business that is outside the cultural norms of its opponents.

Craigslist has been at the center of a huge debate about online prostitution and has been under pressure from the press, politicians and law enforcement to curtail what are obvious solicitations for paid sex services on its site. Craigslist has been attacked by state attorneys general for refusing to remove the section entirely.

Craig Newmark, founder of the site, was even ambushed in an Aug. 13 interview by CNN reporter Amber Lyon (pictured above), who asked him what Craigslist was doing to protect young girls who advertised in the adult services section of the site. She told him that a number of child protection advocates have told her that Craigslist is the “Wal-mart of child sex trafficking.” Under further questioning, Newmark stared at her and referred Lyon to the company’s blog.

Lyon put Newmark on the spot, saying he was the “Craig in Craigslist” and was responsible. In a subsequent blog post, Newmark said that Jim Buckmaster, chief executive, has been running the site for the last 10 years and that his role is as a customer service rep. Newmark said he should have just referred Lyon to Buckmaster, but, instead, he froze on camera and looked “uncaring.” CNN aired the piece dozens of times. Buckmaster, meanwhile, lashed out at Lyon and wrote how Craigslist was trying to do the right thing, manually screening ads in its adult services site since May, 2009. It has also pointed out how similar ads on eBay go unnoticed.

“I know our folks have worked very hard to identify and do the right thing with legitimate versus illegitimate adult service ads,” he said. “From what I can tell, that’s a lot more difficult to do perfectly than is being portrayed by CNN and other media.”

The adult services section has been removed only in the U.S.

http://i.cdn.turner.com/cnn/.element/apps/cvp/3.0/swf/cnn_416x234_embed.swf?context=embed&videoId=international/2010/08/13/bs.lyon.craigslist.sex.cnn

Next Story:
Previous Story:

Tags: ,

Photo of Dean Takahashi

About the Author,

Dean is lead writer for GamesBeat at VentureBeat. He covers video games, security, chips and a variety of other subjects. Dean previously worked at the San Jose Mercury News, the Wall Street Journal, the Red Herring, the Los Angeles Times, the Orange County Register and the Dallas Times Herald. He is the author of two books, Opening the Xbox and the Xbox 360 Uncloaked. Follow him on Twitter at @deantak, and follow VentureBeat on Twitter at @venturebeat.

  • http://twitter.com/direwolff PW

    It's disappointing to see that for the millions of ways to address this issue, sensationalist reporting (good job there Amber & CNN, guess FOX is really putting on the heat on you guys ;) and politicized attorneys general have forced Craigslist to shut down this service. Finally, a centralized place emerges where as a society we can begin to get a handle on the size of this problem in the open, a tool to help law enforcement more easily reach out and find the law breakers and exploiters, and this is the thanks they get? Oy! Even if Craigslist did zero review of the ads, law enforcement could, and it would be better than trying to locate where these criminals will come up for air next. It would also let society as a whole better understand and measure their efforts to address the problem of underage prostitution.The question arises here however, is all the noise from the AGs because they don't actually want to solve this problem? That officer that Amber Lyon talked to in her episode, are you seriously telling me that because Craigslist didn't contact him he couldn't be effective at doing his job by simply going on Craigslist for himself? I smell several rats using Craigslist are their scapegoat. A damn shame :(

  • http://twitter.com/justbrianwilson Brian Wilson

    PW, I agree with much of what you say but Craigslist is responsible for how this played out. They could have treated this problem as seriously as it is and took proactive, tough action to help police nab these human traffickers. We are talking about human slavery here. Women forced into a terrible existence by people who think they own them.That video of Craig was hugely effective. Even though Craig Newmark does truly work customer service at his site, he can still hire and fire the CEO which makes him “the boss.” The fact that he couldn't give basic answers about this when he was surprised by the reporter suggests (while true or not) that he had not put much serious thought in this at all. That this terrible problem was not even on his radar.

  • http://radioheads.net/ RadioHeads

    Да уж…

  • http://twitter.com/sonicdeath Ron Williams

    Craig is being dumb with this. He thinks its about freedom, but being a guy (poorly educated in gender issues) he glosses over the damage to women around the world he is supporting. Craig, would you be selling slaves if Alabama still allowed it?

  • jhonedeep

    the idea that 18 attorneys general, and many others are simply Puritan is naive. There are countless examples of children who are smuggled on Craigslist. This must stop. and Craigslist does not want to stop, because more than one third of its revenues came from adult services section.hindi mp3 songs lyrics

  • http://www.escortsmeet.com/ adult services

    Caving to censors, Craigslist takes down its controversial adult … site Craigslist has taken down the Adult Services section of its site.We jumped at the chance to bring him down and expose everyone to his brand of comedy before he takes over Hollywood. It is like catching U2 at a club …

  • http://bodytut.ru/ костя

    Спасибо за статью!

  • http://bodytut.ru/ костя

    Великолепно!

blog comments powered by Disqus