Glassgate: Could the iPhone 4's glass back be another hardware flaw for Apple?

While Apple seems to be finally moving on from the iPhone 4′s antennagate controversy, the company may be gearing up to deal with a new problem centered around the device’s glass back, gadget site GDGT reports.

Sources tell GDGT that Apple engineers are in a “quiet lockdown” following the events of antennagate because they’ve discovered that non-Bumper cases — those that slide on and cover the rear of the iPhone 4 — could lead to scratching, and potentially full-on fracturing, of the device’s glass back. The cases apparently are prone to particulate matter getting stuck between them and the iPhone 4′s rear, which leads to damage.

As GDGT explains: “To put it another way: Apple is afraid you might buy a standard slide-on iPhone case, put it on your phone, and then discover the next time you take it off that the entire back of your device has been shattered by no fault of your own.”

To counteract this discovery, Apple has apparently removed third-party slide-on cases from its stores. The issue also might explain the unusual shape of Apple’s official Bumper cases, which only protect the sides of the device, and leave the glass back unobstructed.

The news could be fatal for third-party manufacturers who specialize in slide-on cases. Users will also continue to buy the cases outside of Apple’s stores, so if the issue is real, they will continue to be affected.

While the iPhone 4′s glass back is certainly a gorgeous design move, many have questioned its utility since the device was announced. The plastic rear feature on the iPhone 3G and 3G S, and the metal rear on the original iPhone, were all prone to scratches, but at least they wouldn’t shatter if you dropped the phone. As the Wall Street Journal reports, Apple may be looking at an entirely different design for the next iPhone to avoid these issues.

Image via Gizmodo

DB2010Getting content noticed is a challenge for everyone making apps. Join us at DiscoveryBeat 2010 and hear secrets from top industry executives about how to break through and profit in the new cross-platform app ecosystem. From metrics to monetization, we’ll take an in depth look at the best discovery strategies and why they’re working. See the full agenda here. The conference takes place on October 18 at the Mission Bay Conference Center in San Francisco. To register, click here. Hurry though. Tickets are limited, and going fast.

  • bbrewer

    I don't understand this. How is it that the particulate matter could possibly shatter the glass? I can see the potential for some very small surface scratches over time. But, only dropping it or hitting it really hard could shatter the glass, and it would have to be a very hard surface and from quite a distance. I have both a bumper case (thanks Apple) and a wrap around (sides and rear) case. I prefer the bumper case, when I am using one. Also, as far as 'another' flaw goes, what was the FIRST flaw? Antenna gate was TOTALLY BOGUS.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NVHF6V3G4NTN6RRSSB7NAIHAF4 Yozef

    You want a problem with the iPhone. Lack of Flash. It's obvious!

  • http://www.devindra.org Devindra Hardawar

    Um antenna gate was bogus? You mean everyone experiencing reception issues was lying? And Apple gave away free cases for months just for fun? ;) It's not like the screen will crack over night. The particulate matter will slowly cause scratches on the glass over time, which could lead to further damage.

  • bbrewer

    iPhone is not the only phone that can lose cell reception, duh. And Apple got almost NO COMPLAINTS on this.What I think happened was a lot of Windows and Android fanboys playing with other people's phones. If you bridge the antennas, the indicator goes down. But if you had any decent signal at all, then you did not lose or drop the call. This just turned into a FUD storm, and I am sure it was a lot of fun for you. The media ate it up, of course, without bothering to verify it.Apple was forced to give away the cases, not for fun, but as a response to the story, which was blown totally out of proportion.Your thesis about dust scratching the tempered glass is even more absurd, however.

  • bbrewer

    Hahaha, that's a good one. FLASH is garbage, plain and simple, and I don't miss it in the slightest. But I guess if you spend a lot of time playing with whack-a-mole ads, you could. Flash won't run on any cell phone, and never has. Flash lite is not flash. I turn it off in my browser, and I get a real performance boost from it, and don't have to worry about all it's security problems either.

  • http://www.devindra.org Devindra Hardawar

    You really should be getting paid by Apple, you're doing a great job of repeating the company line.

  • bbrewer

    Ha ha, I have the phone. Do you? It's my first iPhone, and I was quite shocked to see this all go down. When the 'story' surfaced it was a worry to me as I had just ordered it. Imagine my surprise when it was shipped and I found it was all a bunch of lies. I could not even get the bars to drop unless my had was wet. I am quite sure most of the videos were contrived by fanboys.What I am doing is responding to your claims. Since you apparently can't back them up, I suppose you just decided to attack my character instead.

  • http://www.devindra.org Devindra Hardawar

    So this is your first iPhone? That just makes you uninformed. I have the iPhone 4 and had the iPhone 3G S previously. Also I never attacked your character, I was stating the fact that you're doing a very good job of repeating Apple's excuses. You say Apple received no complaints, when that wasn't really true. You assume Windows and Android fanboys are just making things up. You don't even realize how fragile the iPhone's glass can be. I realize you like your phone, but that doesn't make it perfect.

  • bbrewer

    You keep changing your tune. First you had some bizarre claim about dust or whatever shattering the glass, and now you are just saying that the iPhone 4 isn't perfect. Hey, I can agree with that.But the antenna gate thing? That was just not true on so many levels. And apparently the reception on the iPhone 4 is better than the earlier models. Guess you didn't want to do a story on that though.

  • bbrewer

    No, you aren't attacking my character at all, just calling me 'uninformed' for trying to correct your outrageous claims. Nice one. There were, according to Apple, only about 1% of the phones returned. That is a very low number. Maybe Apple fudged this claim a bit, do you have evidence of that or not? Do you know anyone who returned their phone? IF it was a PROBLEM, why didn't you return YOURS????Now I know you are going to whine that I am a company parrot, but can you dispute this or not? Sure the Android and Windows fanboys never ever would say anything bad about an Apple product. Just like the Apple fanboys would never say anything untoward about Android or Windows. Arguing with you is like shooting fish in a barrel.

  • http://www.devindra.org Devindra Hardawar

    I use my iPhone with a case, lots of other people I know are also relying on cases or taping over the antenna band gaps.The antenna was a problem that tons of people were able to replicate, including myself, so if you're saying that the problem didn't exist you'd be wrong. People most affected found ways around the issue but still wanted to continue using the phone, that doesn't seem so farfetched. I'm sorry that somehow news of another potential issue has gotten you so worked up, but why be so defensive about it? Also if you read my iPhone 4 review, I mentioned that it got better reception despite the antenna issue. But I guess you didn't want to read.I don't think you know what shooting fish in a barrel means.

  • bbrewer

    So, it was a 'problem' but it was a better antenna. That makes no sense. How would you have any idea of my knowledge of common idioms? Again, you CAN'T REFUTE anything, so you just INSULT me. You are a clown, I will not waste any more time responding to you, so make up whatever non-sense will. Have a good life.

  • http://www.devindra.org Devindra Hardawar

    It has a better antenna with some significant flaws if held in a certain way. How is that hard to process? I've already refuted several things you've said, but you just keep repeating what Apple has said in the past, like the iPhone returns figure. So long kid.

blog comments powered by Disqus