Privacy spat heats up: Google taunts Facebook with "Trap My Data" feature

The battle of sass between Google and Facebook got a lot hotter today, when Google lobbed another grenade at Facebook’s policies on user data by specifically asking users if they want to potentially compromise their friends’ information by uploading it to Facebook.

Google essentially declared war last week on the social network by blocking Facebook from importing contacts from Gmail — a step Facebook takes to check to see which friends you email with might already be signed up for the social network — because, Google says, it believes “data should be free” and Facebook does not allow easy exporting of your friends’ contact information.

Facebook responded by asking users to simply upload a file of their friends’ contacts, thereby bypassing Google’s blocking efforts.

Now the search giant is striking back by allowing the file download, but first directing users to a sarcastically named “Trap My Data” page that asks them if they are “super sure” they want to be “locking up your contact data about your friends.”

In a multi-paragraph explanation, Google lays out its concerns about how Facebook may use the data it collects and even allowing any (potentially) outraged participants to click a box that will “register a complaint over data protectionism.”

Google, however, has engaged in similar data protectionism with its Orkut social network, a Facebook employee recently pointed out, in a move to fend off Facebook’s growing popularity in Orkut’s strongholds of Brazil and India..

How much this openness vs. proprietary ideology has to do with Google’s launch of its own rumored social network, Google Me, widely expected sometime this year, remains to be seen. But we can be sure that Google is declaring early on and vociferously that although Facebook may be by far the world’s most dominant player, it does not have the right to bully other competitors to play by its rules.

The full text of Google’s new “warning” page follows:

Trap My Data

Hold on a second. Are you super sure you want to import your contact information for your friends into a service that won’t let you get it out?

Here’s the not-so-fine print. You have been directed to this page from a site that doesn’t allow you to re-export your data to other services, essentially locking up your contact data about your friends. So once you import your data there, you won’t be able to get it out. We think this is an important thing for you to know before you import your data there. Although we strongly disagree with this data protectionism, the choice is yours. Because, after all, you should have control over your data.

Of course, you are always free to download your contacts using the export feature in Google Contacts.

This public service announcement is brought to you on behalf of your friends in Google Contacts.

Register a complaint over data protectionism. (Google will not record or display your name or email address.)
Proceed with exporting this data. I recognize that once it’s been imported to another service, that service may not allow me to export it back out.

Select one or more options.

  • http://www.bigjobsboard.com Steve Jobs

    I see Google’s point and I agree with them. I mean, I own my data and I must have control over them on whom and where I want to share it. No websites should bar me from sharing or not sharing it to others.

  • BillBlackfield

    Google's point is fair and what they have done is completely right. They are just protecting their users. The fact that facebook found a hack around this shows how unethical facebook is. It shows to what length facebook can go to get user data. Users should realise this and quit facebook. I have quit facebook and am waiting for a safer social networking platform like MyCube or Diaspora to release

  • michaeljones2010

    facebook is obsessed with getting user data and will not take NO for an answer. it is just concerned with exploiting its user base. google has done a right thing by not getting involved in this mess with facebook. facebook is an extremely unsafe platform and acts like this show that facebook can go to any extent. i have deactivated my account as well and will be switching to a safer webiste such as Diaspora or MyCube as soon as they launch

  • rileymcdermid

    so what do you think will be the next salvo in this little war?

  • rileymcdermid

    really? you were so unhappy with their stand on data that you quit entirely? how long ago?

  • rileymcdermid

    wow, so you quit too? how long ago and what set you off?

blog comments powered by Disqus