Engadget editor departs, slams the new “AOL way”

We’ve been hearing that some of AOL’s employees are unhappy with the company’s growing focus on boosting traffic above all else, but until now that has been limited to anonymous complaints and vague reports of discontent. Today, however, AOL-owned Engadget lost a longtime editor, and he didn’t leave quietly.

Paul J. Miller announced his departure from Engadget on his personal blog. Judging from his earliest post, Miller has been at Engadget since September 2005. For context, that’s around the time that AOL acquired Engadget’s owner Weblogs, Inc., and it’s also a year before VentureBeat was founded — Miller has been at the gadget news site for a while.

So why leave now? After the usual thank yous and reminiscences about his time at Engadget, Miller explains his discontent with his current employers:

I’d love to be able to keep doing this forever, but unfortunately Engadget is owned by AOL, and AOL has proved an unwilling partner in this site’s evolution. It doesn’t take a veteran of the publishing world to realize that AOL has its heart in the wrong place with content. As detailed in the “AOL Way,” and borne out in personal experience, AOL sees content as a commodity it can sell ads against. That might make good business sense (though I doubt it), but it doesn’t promote good journalism or even good entertainment, and it doesn’t allow an ambitious team like the one I know and love at Engadget to thrive.

Miller is referring specifically to a company document that was leaked to Business Insider back in January that outlined “The AOl Way,” an ambitious plan to increase the company’s traffic that emphasizes every blog post must be a moneymaker.

As part of chief executive Tim Armstrong’s plans to turn the company around, AOL has also been making some high-profile acquisitions, like the popular tech news site TechCrunch and the even more popular political news site The Huffington Post. In both cases, one of the first questions that came up was how long Armstrong can keep the sites’ editors around.

To be clear, I haven’t seen any signs that either TechCrunch’s Michael Arrington or The HuffPo’s Arianna Huffington are about to head out the door. But it looks like Armstrong’s direction is making some writers mad, and he can’t hold on to everyone.

[image of Armstrong and Huffington via Yfrog/Arianna Huffington]

  • http://ucentric.org ϋCentric

    Nice to finally see some integrity rearing it's elegant head in SF. Let's hope it is contagious…

  • http://www.bigjobsboard.com/ Brad Jobs

    “Every blog post must be a moneymaker.” Is he serious about this? It will look like every post is a marketing article for a certain product or service. They will lose readership if they continue with their plan.

  • http://www.venturebeat.com Anthony Ha

    Well, “moneymaker” in the sense that it must receive enough pageviews that the advertising revenue exceeds the amount spent on the article (i.e., the writer's pay and expenses) by a healthy margin.

  • http://www.searchthenetnow.com/aol-pushes-into-pandoras-box/2011/06/28/ AOL Pushes Into Pandora’s Box

    [...] original editorial voice across all its services"–which certainly chimes with AOL's expansionist agenda.The net streaming music game is very dynamic right now, and it's not yet clear how Apple's iCloud [...]

  • http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/fastcompany/headlines/~3/wiEYvoHPVm0/aol-pandora-slacker-radio-streaming-music-huffington AOL Pushes Into Pandora's Box | Fast Company

    [...] original editorial voice across all its services"–which certainly chimes with AOL's expansionist agenda.The net streaming music game is very dynamic right now, and it's not yet clear how Apple's iCloud [...]

  • http://www.broadfieldmedia.com/2011/06/28/aol-pushes-into-pandoras-box/ Broadfield Media – AOL Pushes Into Pandora’s Box

    [...] The deal will “enable Slacker to deliver its new radio offerings to a larger audience,” according to the news release. It’s also a chance to “develop new advertising opportunities for mutual clients,”–a nod to the monetary motivation here. Plus, Slacker can now “integrate AOL Music’s original editorial voice across all its services”–which certainly chimes with AOL’s expansionist agenda. [...]

  • http://prbuilder.com/news/techcruncher-quits-slams-new-editor%e2%80%94on-techcrunch/ TechCruncher Quits, Slams New Editor—On TechCrunch | PRbuilder.com

    [...] So will other TechCrunch writers be following Carr's example? AOL's tactics seem to have driven other writers away in the past, with a number of writers and editors at gadget site Engadget resigning this year, and at least one of them blaming a new strategy called “the AOL Way.” [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus