Microsoft's Bing sees Twitter backlash for Japan quake campaign

Here’s a great example of how a seemingly noble social media donation campaign can go awry: Microsoft tweeted two hours ago on the Bing search engine’s Twitter account that it would donate up to $100,000 to help victims of Japan’s earthquake — but only if Twitter users retweeted its original post to broadcast it to their followers, at $1 per retweet.

While many Twitter users are retweeting without complaint, others are pointing out that this campaign seems like a crass marketing opportunity for Bing.

Comedian Michael Ian Black, who has nearly 1.6 million Twitter followers, graphically responded to the campaign with this tweet: “Hey @bing, stop using a tragedy as a fucking marketing opportunity.” Searching for “@Bing” on Twitter at the time of this post reveals plenty of other users who aren’t taking too kindly to Microsoft’s campaign.

This backlash shows us that as useful as social media is for inspiring activism, it must be carefully deployed so as not to seem like a craven publicity stunt. Most recently, we saw a similar backlash to Kenneth Cole’s tweet about Cairo amid Egypt’s recent protests, in which the fashion label plugged its spring collection.

I can’t imagine how Microsoft didn’t see this coming. It would have received plenty of good will by simply donating $100,000 to help out quake victims. This campaign, on the other hand, seems like a forced attempt to get people talking about Bing, and ultimately to get it trending on Twitter. Now people are indeed talking about Bing, but Microsoft likely won’t appreciate what they’re saying.

Update: the Bing folks have now apologized and will donate the full $100,000 amount to help the quake victims.

Tweet image via Ethan Maffey

  • http://twitter.com/mikeyarbrough Mike Yarbrough

    Ironically, it may just get trending… but for the wrong reasons.

  • http://jza.myopenid.com/ JZA

    yaaay everyone tweet @Bing is stained with Japanese blood.

  • http://twitter.com/robertmclaws Robert McLaws

    So because one comedian woke up in a bad mood, that makes it a backlash? Hmmm… Way to make something out of nothing.

  • http://twitter.com/Kalanac John David Chapman

    I'm glad I wasn't the only one to feel this way about this appauling behaviour. By all means get the message out but this is just marketing. It makes no ethical sense to only donate based on re-tweets. If you're gonna donate $100k then just do it!

  • http://www.devindra.org Devindra Hardawar

    Do a twitter search and you'll find plenty of people saying the same thing.

  • http://robvincent.net Rob T Firefly

    Really glad I wasn't the only one who felt this way. I'm fully capable of donating my own dollar or more directly to a charity without being a recruited spammer for Microsoft, thanks.

  • http://twitter.com/GrrAargh .

    I complained to @Bing about it and I don't know that comedian.

  • mike2k

    I've seen hundreds of twitter accounts that claim to donate $1to cancer funding per retweet yet know one cries about that. As soon as MS does it for disaster struck Japan, it's a scam for publicity. There's nothing wrong here.

  • http://gonehiking.wordpress.com/ Brian

    Quit your griping, are you going to send $100k to Japan?

  • tribalknowledgetv

    It would appear that this is a high profile case of an apparent “social media” expert being let loose on behalf of Microsoft. I always love those people who have 200,000 followers and endless “likes” who claim to be social media experts. Brain still required.

  • digerati007

    I was on the http://www.apple.com page today & they have a small Red Cross donation button that takes you to the Red Cross website if you WISH to make a donation & how MUCH you wish to donate.This is the professional & classy way to get the message out & lead you to the RED CROSS website to find out more information.Simple. Caring. Humble.

  • DungWung

    that actually makes perfect sense dude.http://www.privacy-tools.cz.tc

  • http://www.devindra.org Devindra Hardawar

    Glad to see everyone is thinking hard about this situation.

  • DazzlingD

    Lets's see if the world's second largest company donates as much as they did for Haiti.Oh yeah, it was NOTHING…!I guess that puts the $3.5M that Microsoft donated to Haiti in real perspective.

  • digerati007

    Miss the point entirely as you did not read all the other replies on this page & social media sites about this situation & MS blunder in their PR DEPARTMENT.MS donation? GOOD!MS PR? BAD!Also this is not a Mac & PC thing so put the flame thrower down.Finally, Many musicians put together relief for Haiti songs, albums, etc to generate funds for people in Haiti which is a GOOD thing to do. Apple / iTunes promoted those albums & DONATED all of the Apple proceeds from those song sales to HAITI too. So the Artist & Apple gave all the money made to Haiti Relief Fund.Finally, it is a policy of some corporations to highly promote to the employees to give back to the community & “Pay It Forward”. But, many companies & the PR team DO NOT USE donations to charities as a way to promote themselves as a company. BAD FORM! Apple is just one of those companies.After all it IS about the CHARITY, not about NOTORIETY.THAT was the point of this discussion on DISCUS.

  • http://themodernmarketer.wordpress.com/2011/06/13/three-social-media-marketing-techniques-that-brands-should-probably-ditch/ Three social media marketing techniques that brands should probably ditch « The Modern Marketer

    [...] obvious reasons, Microsoft’s attempt to do good didn’t go over too well, and instead of improving its image, Microsoft has arguably damaged [...]

  • http://zeeahmed.wordpress.com/2011/06/14/sm-strategy-for-small-businesses/ SM strategy for small businesses « A Curious Boy
  • http://novuscorp.ca/site/archives/3519 The 10 biggest mistakes small businesses can make online | Novus Professional Corp

    [...] Problem was, lots of people immediately wondered why the company couldn’t just give the $100,000 regardless. In other words, why try to turn a tragedy into a marketing opportunity? [...]

  • http://leomoo.com/2011/11/the-10-biggest-mistakes-small-businesses-can-make-online/ The 10 biggest mistakes small businesses can make online | Leomoo.com

    [...] Problem was, lots of people immediately wondered why the company couldn’t just give the $100,000 regardless. In other words, why try to turn a tragedy into a marketing opportunity? [...]

  • http://mattcornell.org/blog/2012/01/lessons-in-marketing-a-look-at-the-cafe-50s-calendar/ My Own Private Guantanamo

    [...] was busted for shameless opportunism twice, first for using the Japanese earthquake to promote brand awareness for Bing and next for using the death of Amy Winehouse to promote sales of her music at their Zune [...]

  • http://amandacohaver.wordpress.com/2012/03/06/bingforjapan-2/ Bing Tweets for Japan | Amanda O'Haver

    [...] willing to donate money to the relief effort. Bing, the Internet search engine, was one of them.Bing decided to go about donating money in a different way than everyone else. They were going to donate [...]

  • http://paidcontent.org/2011/03/14/419-the-morning-lowdown-03-15-11/ The Morning Lowdown 03-14-11 — paidContent

    [...] »  Microsoft’s Bing sees Twitter backlash for Japan quake campaign [...]

  • http://audreyetlescomm.wordpress.com/2012/12/02/essai2/ Essai #2 : Twitter pour toutes les occasions « Audrey Croteau

    [...] Bing sees Twitter backlash for Japan quake campaign ». VentureBeat. 12 mars. [En ligne] URL : http://venturebeat.com/2011/03/12/bing-sees-backlash-for-japan-quake-donation-campaign/. Consulté le 01 décembre [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus