When people talk about creating an artificial intelligence, the conversation is often focused on human or superhuman AI — systems that would equal or surpass us in intelligence. But what if we create an artificial intelligence that’s deserving of respect, but don’t recognize it as such?
That’s a question I’ve had bouncing around in my head for the past several months. Over the course of human history, we’ve proven very poor as a species at successfully evaluating the intelligence of other beings, whether they’re human or non-human. Consider crows, who learn from their dead, recognize individuals, use tools, and even bring gifts to those they like — are they … intelligent?
Furthermore, if we were to create an AI that produced those characteristics, does it require the same sort of considerations that a crow does, with regards to its treatment at the hands of humanity? We likely won’t have to reckon with a human-level AI for many years, but these questions could prove more pressing.
What’s disconcerting to me about this conversation is that we don’t seem to have a good framework for dealing with questions like these, when it comes to analogues elsewhere in the animal kingdom.
Take octopuses, for instance, which have proven to be highly intelligent and talented escape artists. Should they — or AIs that match them in intelligence — be treated differently because of the way their brains work? And how will companies treat this same question as their research pushes ever closer to that territory? Will the tastes of various executives, like Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos, who enjoys breakfast octopus, lead to similarly unequal treatment?
I don’t have a great answer, especially as someone who has been known to enjoy octopus. But as we reckon with the consequences of AI in 2018, I think considering differences in intelligence is important. Over the course of human history, we’ve at times decided that even other humans are unworthy of compassion or fair treatment because of a perceived lack of intelligence or nonconformance with the norms imposed by a dominant culture.
And we have to wrestle with all of that while remaining skeptical of claims around artificial intelligence so as to not fall victim to bot overhype. Welcome to the new year.
Thanks for reading,
Blair Hanley Frank
AI Staff Writer
P.S. Please enjoy this video of Kate Crawford’s keynote at NIPS 2017 about AI and bias.
From the AI Channel
AImotive raises $38 million for self-driving car software
Europe’s AImotive has raised $38 million in a third round of funding for its software for autonomous cars. Budapest, Hungary-based AImotive has specialized in making software that can take the data from autonomous car cameras and sensors and then identify pedestrians and other hazards for the artificial intelligence driving system to avoid. The company announced […]
Why bots go bad: Curbing transgressive tendencies in AI
GUEST: From Microsoft’s accidentally racist bot to Inspirobot’s dark memes, AI often wanders into transgressive territories. Why does this happen, and can we stop it? In science fiction, artificial intelligence is often characterized by amoral villainy. From 2001: A Space Odyssey’s HAL to the robotic agents in The Matrix, AI is a convenient and believable baddie, […]
Turn your Amazon Echo into a smart home security system
GUEST: If you’ve just unwrapped an Amazon Echo hub, now is the perfect time to connect it and its digital voice assistant, Alexa, to your home security system. With a two-year head start over the rest of the digital assistant market, Alexa’s repertoire of skills and compatible products is incredibly vast. There’s an almost endless selection […]
10 predictions for deep learning in 2018
GUEST: I’ve got this ominous feeling that 2018 could be the year that everything changes dramatically. The incredible breakthroughs we saw in 2017 for deep learning will carry over in a very powerful way in 2018. A lot of work coming from 2017’s research will migrate into everyday software applications. As I did last year, I’ve […]
AI operators will play a critical role as bots redefine the workplace
GUEST: Treating AI like it’s a person has its benefits. When IBM named its AI “Watson,” the company hoped people would see it as warm and approachable, a “humble genius” even. According to Ann Rubin, vice president of branded content and global creative at IBM, in a conversation with Adweek, it worked. It’s no surprise then […]
Everything Amazon’s Alexa learned to do in 2017
Amazon’s Alexa is leading the AI assistant pack. Echo devices are dominating smart speaker sales, and that was before Amazon brought the devices to more than 80 nations around the world. To defend its crown, Amazon moved fast this year to outpace competitors like Google Assistant and Microsoft’s Cortana. Apple’s delayed HomePod is due out […]
I Spent a Week Living With Chatbots—Did All That Self-Help Help?
Recently, I was hungry. So I told the Whole Foods chatbot what I had in my fridge, and it revealed that a bacon, lettuce, and heirloom tomato sandwich was mine for the making. Yum. Then, out of boredom, I booted up the movie-recommendation bot And Chill, which suggested I watch Jake Gyllenhaal repeatedly relive the last day of his life in Source Code. I shuddered every time the train exploded. (via Wired)
Deep Learning for Cosmetics
At Mira, we build tools that empower beauty enthusiasts to learn, gather inspiration and make informed buying decisions. In conversations with over 75 beauty consumers, we’ve learned that one of the foremost challenges that a consumer faces in finding the right products and techniques is identifying authentic and authoritative voices who can speak to their individual concerns. (via Medium)
AI and Deep Learning in 2017 – A Year in Review
The year is coming to an end. I did not write nearly as much as I had planned to. But I’m hoping to change that next year, with more tutorials around Reinforcement Learning, Evolution, and Bayesian Methods coming to WildML! And what better way to start than with a summary of all the amazing things that happened in 2017? (via WildML)
How an A.I. ‘Cat-and-Mouse Game’ Generates Believable Fake Photos
The woman in the photo seems familiar. She looks like Jennifer Aniston, the “Friends” actress, or Selena Gomez, the child star turned pop singer. But not exactly. (via The New York Times)
These stickers make computer vision software hallucinate things that aren’t there
If you’re trying to fool an AI vision system in the future, then stickers like these might help. (via The Verge)